Live data from Hacker News

LinkedIn is scanning browser extensions

404privacy.com

121–130 of 226 posts

Re: LinkedIn is scanning browser extensions

#121
post #13

friends, WHEN you are asked to implement something like this at your job, which will you choose: object (& hold ground, loose job) OR comply (& keep job) as practitioners, where do we hold the line between telemetry and surveillance?

I choose not to work at places like linked in, meta, or any place that accepts Saudi or Israeli funding. It makes it a little harder to find a job, but i sleep better at night.

For similar reasons, I have been working in the public sector (Australian state government) for the past 5 years and couldn’t be happier.

I’m lucky that I’m in a team which is hands on and does a lot of very interesting things. From building CRUD apps which are used in management and response to bushfires (wildfires) to more interesting things like building a datalake which amalgamates and stores weather data from multiple sources to building near real time CDC pipelines and making our transactional data available to our in house team of data scientists who then use that data to do fascinating stuff that eventually results in for example making sure that our response to bushfires takes into account the impact and safety of endangered species.

And when I look at the underlying data and the trends and and projections of just how bad bushfires are going to get in the next 30 years and how we must be so much nimbler and smarter just to survive, the work takes on a whole new level of meaning.

Don’t get me wrong, there are times the internal bureaucracy absolutely drives me mad. And I am aware that I could be earning much more in the private sector. But I get to work with a team who are really passionate and enthusiastic about their job, and I get to sleep at night knowing that unlike my previous jobs, this time I am not just making someone who is already uber rich, richer.

If you had told the teenage Utilitarian me that I would one day work for, and enjoy working for, government, I would have thought hell must have frozen over.

Re: LinkedIn is scanning browser extensions

#122
post #29

Can someone here please create a LinkedIn replacement for developers that 1. Doesn't have the spam 2. That doesn't look like it's from 2008 3. That only developers / engineers / tech folks can join 4. Doesn't try to log into your email to steal your contact list 5. That doesn't track you or your extensions / browser fingerprint 6. That doesn't have a bunch of fake "linkedinmaxxing" garbage content 7. that doesn't hav…

Seriously. We need some kind of federated replacement. Who is building this?

sifa.id aspires to that.

Wishing Guido (gui.do) the best.

Re: LinkedIn is scanning browser extensions

#123
post #29

Can someone here please create a LinkedIn replacement for developers that 1. Doesn't have the spam 2. That doesn't look like it's from 2008 3. That only developers / engineers / tech folks can join 4. Doesn't try to log into your email to steal your contact list 5. That doesn't track you or your extensions / browser fingerprint 6. That doesn't have a bunch of fake "linkedinmaxxing" garbage content 7. that doesn't hav…

Stack Exchange sort of tried to do this. It never seemed to get off the ground.

Re: LinkedIn is scanning browser extensions

#124
post #112

[flagged]

What's the reason you asked this question? I mean, yeah, you could have stayed silent, and nowadays everyone assumes that pointing out obvious things in a condescending tone is kind of insightful, just because you used enough ellipses. Back then we all knew: vague rhetorical questions aren't arguments. Technically, it's not a big surprise at all that someone would restate "you are the product" like it's a revelation.…

On the one hand, this really sounds frustrated, and I know why you are (bcs we both know that I'm right).

But beyond that unhappy story, your comment actually made me smile. Linguistically, let's say. And there is no sarcasm at all. It was funny to read!!

Re: LinkedIn is scanning browser extensions

#127
post #61
post #49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I guess that's what they're hoping for. With my admittedly biased opinion of the average linkedin user, about 99% will have the default set of extensions installed and so will not be very useful. Those users might have other identifiers of course, so who knows.

I’m pretty sure it’s not 99% you would wonder how many differences there are along with user-agent resolution and ip range... I think 99% are identifiable

Ideally about 99% of LinkedIn users are using their professional name, occupation, and location.

Re: LinkedIn is scanning browser extensions

#128
post #71
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It isn’t exactly. They created a list of known extensions by their id and a file which is known to exist in that extension. The site iterates over each pair and tries to load that file, if it doesn’t error it knows the extension is installed. It’s a clever and difficult manual process, but it does bypass the security trying to prevent this kind of thing. I read that their reasoning is it exists to block users that us…

Does the same scan is happening on firefox? Random websites invoking extensions do seem to be a security hole to me.

This was posted before and it seems that Firefox randomizes the extension URLs.

Re: LinkedIn is scanning browser extensions

#129

and, recently while trying to decipher why computer was at 98% memory and 65% cpu one of the culprits is https://li.protechts.net taking 2GB ram and 8% cpu. DDG searches say this is something for linkedin. - I had two tabs for linkedin open but left behind as I opened other tabs to research. So I had not reopened these tabs in over 9 hours and they are still just humming along sucking down almost 10% of cpu and a cou…

Thanks for flagging this, I was literally seeing the same thing with protechts.net in my activity tab this morning as I was trying to understand why firefox was aggressively draining my battery.

Re: LinkedIn is scanning browser extensions

#130
post #125
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And certainly fingerprint you right?

Probably mostly for abuse prevention. Lots of extensions like this one: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/linkedin-data...

The "abuse" is that one doesn't have to copy paste for hours.
Post reply on HN