Live data from Hacker News

U.S. war in Iran has cost $25B so far, says Pentagon official

reuters.com

41–50 of 193 posts

Re: U.S. war in Iran has cost $25B so far, says Pentagon official

#41
post #22

I remember before the election I read a few people on HN say Trump is the most anti-war president they have ever seen and that all the talk about him letting Israel flatten Palestine was fearmongering. Wonder how they feel now.

They definitely don't feel remorse.

Re: U.S. war in Iran has cost $25B so far, says Pentagon official

#42
post #22

I remember before the election I read a few people on HN say Trump is the most anti-war president they have ever seen and that all the talk about him letting Israel flatten Palestine was fearmongering. Wonder how they feel now.

I think he ran on ending "forever wars", not whether or not Israel could flatten Palestine. He would probably also argue that Iran is a 47 year forever war that he is finally ending.

Re: U.S. war in Iran has cost $25B so far, says Pentagon official

#43
By the way, this is just the estimate from Pete Hegseth, who has demonstrated himself to be an unreliable narrator. This administration seems to have difficulty with numbers in general, accurate numbers in particular. The real cost is likely twice this, or higher.

For example, roughly 50% of our missile stockpiles have been depleted during this "excursion."

Re: U.S. war in Iran has cost $25B so far, says Pentagon official

#45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Note that it doesn't count the cost of second- or third- order effects (like the cost from the price of oil going up by 50%). Since February 28, crude oil prices increases cost $42 billion in the United States alone.

What are the second- and third order effects of the Marg Bar Amrika Society getting a nuclear device (and the missiles to deliver it)?

Peace in that region of the world, since you can't just bomb Iran consequence free anymore?

MAD has had its virtues extolled, yet assume it won't work with another country because somehow they are even more irrational (if true). Even though that is exactly for whom the MAD strategy is designed and operates under.

It is only the build up of Iran getting a nuclear weapon that is used to go to war.

The game theory here seems rather simple, honestly.

And if Iran is seen as hostile, we need to look at the countries for whom the USA allies with and what wars they launched in the region. And they are plausible nuclear capable where their neighbors are not.

I think Israel is currently a larger aggressor, literally flattening more towns through demolition.

Re: U.S. war in Iran has cost $25B so far, says Pentagon official

#47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What was gained from it?

It successfully diverted attention away from the Trump-Epstein Files. "Mission Accomplished"

If that is the case why do I see this comment every 5 minutes?

Re: U.S. war in Iran has cost $25B so far, says Pentagon official

#48
post #38
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Probably comparable to North Korea getting a nuclear device and the missiles to deliver it.

Does North Korea send missiles and drones to it's neighbors?

Yes. North Korea has a long history of exporting arms and missile technology to both its neighbors and further afield, including to Iran.

Re: U.S. war in Iran has cost $25B so far, says Pentagon official

#49

For context Doge saved 2-3 billion by independent estimates. And cut some of the most important international aid around the world.

Not only aid, it was a powerful tool for the extension of American soft power around the globe. But I guess we're no longer able to reason in the abstract beyond "helping people is woke."

Re: U.S. war in Iran has cost $25B so far, says Pentagon official

#50
post #36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Note that it doesn't count the cost of second- or third- order effects (like the cost from the price of oil going up by 50%). Since February 28, crude oil prices increases cost $42 billion in the United States alone.

It's so odd to me that people think the cost of oil going up is universally bad. It's good both morally for me and financially for many people.

The consequences to everyone that isn't as well fed as yourself are also good for you morally?
Post reply on HN