Live data from Hacker News

New gas-powered data centers could emit more greenhouse gases than whole nations

wired.com

1–10 of 147 posts

Re: New gas-powered data centers could emit more greenhouse gases than whole nations

#2
> New gas projects linked to just 11 data center campuses around the US have the potential to create more greenhouse gases than the country of Morocco emitted in 2024

"Have the potential to", "Morocco". Presumably doesn't count the greenhouse gases emitted by Moroccans using overseas cloud services and AI.

At least the example wasn't Vatican City.

Re: New gas-powered data centers could emit more greenhouse gases than whole nations

#4
Very quick Googling suggests Wired’s estimate would be ~1.9% of US emissions.

AI data center investment is, at core, a bet on increasing the productivity of labor. That’s what businesses will pay for, and what will earn the big money.

If US labor productivity rises by more than 2%—and implicit in the size of this bet is a guess much higher—US carbon intensity goes down correspondingly, and these data centers end up as a win for the climate.

Re: New gas-powered data centers could emit more greenhouse gases than whole nations

#6
post #3

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2026/apr/01/iran-energy-cr... It’s quite impressive how the world is unable to reduce greenhouse emissions.

In history of the world there was almost never a reduction of greenhouse emissions. Only time that world did reduce greenhouse emissions was in times of economic crises and COVID-19.

https://ourworldindata.org/co2-emissions

Asia will do what US did in 1979, Jimmy Carter delivered this televised speech on July 15, 1979.

"Point three: To give us energy security, I am asking for the most massive peacetime commitment of funds and resources in our nation's history to develop America's own alternative sources of fuel -- from coal, from oil shale, from plant products for gasohol, from unconventional gas, from the sun."

https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/americanexperience/features/carter-...

Re: New gas-powered data centers could emit more greenhouse gases than whole nations

#7
post #4

Very quick Googling suggests Wired’s estimate would be ~1.9% of US emissions. AI data center investment is, at core, a bet on increasing the productivity of labor. That’s what businesses will pay for, and what will earn the big money. If US labor productivity rises by more than 2%—and implicit in the size of this bet is a guess much higher—US carbon intensity goes down correspondingly, and these data centers end up a…

[deleted]

Re: New gas-powered data centers could emit more greenhouse gases than whole nations

#9
The AI data center narrative is the perfect storm:

First most of the data center build out is happening in areas that have had little other opportunity so local resistance is muted. Abilene, Texas is referenced and is the kind of place my grandfather would lovingly say is where you go to learn to be a “dirt farmer”

Second, every environmentalist in the US is fighting 100 different battles with the most anti-regulation, pro-energy administration in decades (ever?) and has limited bandwidth.

And third, the AI narrative around national security, longevity, and super-intelligence-enabled abundance provides massive national coverage - the implications being that AI will solve any environmental and or human economic disasters that they enable.

Re: New gas-powered data centers could emit more greenhouse gases than whole nations

#10
post #4

Very quick Googling suggests Wired’s estimate would be ~1.9% of US emissions. AI data center investment is, at core, a bet on increasing the productivity of labor. That’s what businesses will pay for, and what will earn the big money. If US labor productivity rises by more than 2%—and implicit in the size of this bet is a guess much higher—US carbon intensity goes down correspondingly, and these data centers end up a…

You are supposing that with more productivity people will emit less carbon but there's no mechanism for that

More productivity means the employers just demand more from the workers

Post reply on HN