Live data from Hacker News

Reinventing Email

reinventingemail.com

11–20 of 46 posts

Re: Reinventing Email

#11
post #9

>Pixel perfect + Retina + Cloud The trifecta of the mobile apps. Sync all your email and tasks with our cloud based mobile app. The trifecta of buzzwords perhaps.

Thanks for contributing to the conversation with this dismissive, regurgitated comment. What have YOU done lately? Why dismiss something someone has worked hard on?

Re: Reinventing Email

#13
gorgeous UI. could you share the PSD? we'd love to use some of those UI elements on the next version of TaskUp. we're working on an email parsing feature at TaskUp (taskup.com) to extract those usage patterns of email into todo lists and already provide a mechanism of transforming emails into todos by just CCing track@taskup.com on any email. would that be something that you would use? how could we make it better?

Re: Reinventing Email

#14
So... what does it do?

It seems to somehow organize my emails as tasks, but how does that work in practice?

What happens when I get an email? Does it turn it into a task? Can other people still interact as usual with me by email without using this software? What about emails that really are not todo items?

Re: Reinventing Email

#15
You cover only 3 new "features": Tasks + Quick Reply + Sync... how are these reinventive? Tools like rapportive, followupthen and even something simple like find big mail are actually reinventive. To be able to type in an email and get the users social information that I can check and follow up on while writing the email is powerful. To be able to get notifications X days/weeks/months creates the persona you are ON TOP of your game.

Just my 0.02 - I do like ur UI stuff btw :)

Re: Reinventing Email

#16

"Email is not a messaging protocol. It's a todo list." Speak for yourself. My primary use case is to send and receive messages with others. If a message includes things to be done, I'll put them in a TODO list, like I'd do with any other messaging protocol. The reason why reinventing email always fails is because email isn't broken.

The thought of making email more like a todo list is terrifying to me. I try to move valuable information and tasks out of email and into trusted systems that are designed specifically for those purposes as fast as possible. Testing out this guys hypothesis couldn't hurt, but I want nothing to do with it.

I think the reason why reinventing email always fails is that it is generally skin deep.

Re: Reinventing Email

#18
Paul Graham may be a bit out of touch. I've asked around and confirmed that the people in my life, at least, are confused at the idea of using email as a to do list.

But he certainly knows how to get the tools that he wants made for him.

Re: Reinventing Email

#19

"Email is not a messaging protocol. It's a todo list." Speak for yourself. My primary use case is to send and receive messages with others. If a message includes things to be done, I'll put them in a TODO list, like I'd do with any other messaging protocol. The reason why reinventing email always fails is because email isn't broken.

I agree. I think email is broken for people in the manager schedule http://www.paulgraham.com/makersschedule.html

That's why we keep hearing how painful email is from people like PG (someone clearly in the manager schedule) but a lot of makers don't really appreciate the pain

I think the whole 'email is broken' thing should be phrased differently. I agree there is tons of pain. Maybe articulating it well IS the solution?

So I wonder what you guys think. What is the real problem? Who has this problem?

Re: Reinventing Email

#20
Email is great because, at its heart, it's a super-simple Unix-ish concept: send text-based messages to another address. (Granted the history and implementation has grown quite gnarled, but that's not important for day-to-day UX.)

That simplicity is what makes it so compelling: you can twist email to be whatever you want. Some use it as a to-do list, some as a calendar, some for editing documents, some just for messaging. Everyone can use it in a different way because it's so simple and easy to understand.

One can certainly invent products that try to take one aspect of email and improve them, like a to-do list, but then it's not email anymore... it's a to-do/calendar app. Which isn't bad, but the point is--email isn't going anywhere.

Post reply on HN