Live data from Hacker News

Anthropic installed a spyware bridge on my machine?

thatprivacyguy.com

31–36 of 36 posts

Re: Anthropic installed a spyware bridge on my machine?

#31
I would have thought this would be more of a story, I'm surprised there are so few comments.

"Claude Desktop, an Anthropic application, reached across the trust boundary between two independent vendors, and wrote configuration into Brave's application directory. The principle that an application does not silently modify another application is so obvious it rarely gets stated. Anthropic broke it in silence."

This is the key point for me - ask me, let me remove when done. That would be all it takes to not abuse trust.

Re: Anthropic installed a spyware bridge on my machine?

#32

I would have thought this would be more of a story, I'm surprised there are so few comments. "Claude Desktop, an Anthropic application, reached across the trust boundary between two independent vendors, and wrote configuration into Brave's application directory. The principle that an application does not silently modify another application is so obvious it rarely gets stated. Anthropic broke it in silence." This is t…

It's being suppressed by the mods. I'd bet my house on it.

Re: Anthropic installed a spyware bridge on my machine?

#34

I would have thought this would be more of a story, I'm surprised there are so few comments. "Claude Desktop, an Anthropic application, reached across the trust boundary between two independent vendors, and wrote configuration into Brave's application directory. The principle that an application does not silently modify another application is so obvious it rarely gets stated. Anthropic broke it in silence." This is t…

It's being suppressed by the mods. I'd bet my house on it.

Oh thanks that Xteink X4 looks interesting, I'll do some research. Cheers!

Re: Anthropic installed a spyware bridge on my machine?

#35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's being suppressed by the mods. I'd bet my house on it.

Oh thanks that Xteink X4 looks interesting, I'll do some research. Cheers!

Of course I realise way too late I responded to the wrong thread....

Re: Anthropic installed a spyware bridge on my machine?

#36
post #23
post #10

That’s not spyware, that’s just how native messaging is designed to work. You have to put a manifest there if you want the native messaging to work later.

With this argument you could also justify: "That's not a remote access trojan (RAT), that's just how client-server communication is designed to work." > You have to put a manifest there if you want the native messaging to work later. The point is that Claude Desktop didn't ask the user whether they want native messaging in the first place. Which is strange, given that users experience many "Do you grant permission to…

No, it’s more like “installing software installs files on the system”.

That’s not new by any means. It’s no different than zoom installing a native audio plugin for the os, or other software creating files on the system.

Post reply on HN