Live data from Hacker News

A new spam policy for “back button hijacking”

developers.google.com

241–250 of 532 posts

Re: A new spam policy for “back button hijacking”

#241

Some Microsoft sites have been very guilty of this. They are the ones that stick in my head in recent memory.

Epic store makes it impossible to navigate backwards from the checkout on mobile at least. Not sure if it's design or just poor design.

I think most checkouts do that, to prevent duplicate payments. Dunno about epic, but I often encounter that mitigated by a dedicated ‘go back to store’ button post-checkout

Re: A new spam policy for “back button hijacking”

#242

Ok, you can start with LinkedIn, I'll wait... If you are wondering how it works. You get a link from LinkedIn, it's from an email or just a post someone shared. You click on it, the URL loads, and you read the post. When you click the back button, you aren't taken back to wherever you came from. Instead, your LinkedIn feed loads. How did it happen? When you landed on the first link, the URL is replaced with the homep…

The fix is to hold down the back button so the local history shows up, and pick the right page to go back to. Unfortunately, some versions of Chrome and/or Android seem to break this but that's a completely self-inflicted problem.

[deleted]

Re: A new spam policy for “back button hijacking”

#243
post #221

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm pretty sure what you're describing is this long-standing bug[1] I've experienced only when using Mobile Safari on Reddit - affecting both old.reddit.com and the (horrible) modern Reddit. It just doesn't happen in other browsers/engines except on iOS. It's especially annoying on an iPad when I tend to use back/forward instead of open-in-new-tab-then-close on iPhone. [1] At least, I hope it's a bug.

A bug that just coincidentally affects the only reddit visitors that are worth any money?

Just like finally getting rid of r/all on mobile just happens to bury a bunch of political stuff reddit executives and their friends don't agree with

Re: A new spam policy for “back button hijacking”

#247
post #221

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm pretty sure what you're describing is this long-standing bug[1] I've experienced only when using Mobile Safari on Reddit - affecting both old.reddit.com and the (horrible) modern Reddit. It just doesn't happen in other browsers/engines except on iOS. It's especially annoying on an iPad when I tend to use back/forward instead of open-in-new-tab-then-close on iPhone. [1] At least, I hope it's a bug.

A bug that just coincidentally affects the only reddit visitors that are worth any money?

Do you treat every iOS bug this way?

Re: A new spam policy for “back button hijacking”

#248
post #220

Great. Can we do ctrl-f search hijacking next. So jarring when websites replace core functionality with their own broken crap because they think they’re special. Some also seem to hijack right click menu now

Some also hijack the shortcuts to open devtools (like F12), so you have to find the option in the browser menu itself

You can also click the address bar and then press you shortcut. Should be faster and works for all shortcuts AFAIK.

Re: A new spam policy for “back button hijacking”

#250

Ok, you can start with LinkedIn, I'll wait... If you are wondering how it works. You get a link from LinkedIn, it's from an email or just a post someone shared. You click on it, the URL loads, and you read the post. When you click the back button, you aren't taken back to wherever you came from. Instead, your LinkedIn feed loads. How did it happen? When you landed on the first link, the URL is replaced with the homep…

Also www.reddit.com is/was doing the same back button hijacking. From google.com visiting a post, then clicking back and you would find yourself on Reddit general feed instead of back to Google.

IIRC Reddit is also doing the same thing on their mobile (Android) app.
Post reply on HN