Live data from Hacker News

AI Will Be Met with Violence, and Nothing Good Will Come of It

thealgorithmicbridge.com

11–20 of 694 posts

Re: AI Will Be Met with Violence, and Nothing Good Will Come of It

#11

This is nonsense, promoted to top of front page without any comments. How about all the rock stars killed over the years, or grocery store clerks shot and stabbed to death? EVERYTHING is met with violence because that's the nature of aggression no matter the impetus, it doesn't require a justifiable reason, only belief in the outcome of its use. Sam Altman having a Molotov cocktail thrown at his house after Ronan wro…

[flagged]

Re: AI Will Be Met with Violence, and Nothing Good Will Come of It

#12
post #2

> Every time I hear from Amodei or Altman that I could lose my job, I don’t think “oh, ok, then allow me pay you $20/month so that I can adapt to these uncertain times that have fallen upon my destiny by chance.” I think: “you, for fuck’s sake, you are doing this.” And I consider myself a pretty levelheaded guy, so imagine what not-so-levelheaded people think. Conversely, The Loudest Alarm Is Probably False[0]. If th…

Related, I've been surprised that we haven't had more violence against corporations and/or their leadership in the vein of Luigi Mangione.

E.g., suppose that 1,000,000 persons believe that a corporation's evil acts destroyed their happiness [0]. I would have guessed that at least 1 person in that crowd would be so unhinged by the experience that they'd make a viable attempt at vengeance.

But I'm just not hearing of that happening, at least not nearly to the extent I would have guessed. I'm curious where my thinking is wrong.

[0] E.g., big tobacco, the Sacklers with Oxycontin, insurance companies delaying lifesaving treatment, or the Bhopal disaster.

Re: AI Will Be Met with Violence, and Nothing Good Will Come of It

#14

This is nonsense, promoted to top of front page without any comments. How about all the rock stars killed over the years, or grocery store clerks shot and stabbed to death? EVERYTHING is met with violence because that's the nature of aggression no matter the impetus, it doesn't require a justifiable reason, only belief in the outcome of its use. Sam Altman having a Molotov cocktail thrown at his house after Ronan wro…

People here are extra anxious about the impact of AI on their lives, so I am not surprised that any text which touches the topic gets upvoted.

We are somewhat violent species, so I agree that almost every significant economic and societal development has the potential to trigger some violence. That said, the jobs that are potentially threatened by AI are nowadays usually done by fairly sedentary people, so I wouldn't expect any large-scale violence, an occasional Ted Kaczynski notwithstanding. Programmers, translators and painters just aren't used to destroying things in the real world.

It would have been different if AI started to replace drug dealers or the mob.

Re: AI Will Be Met with Violence, and Nothing Good Will Come of It

#15

The worst part is that AI's first casualties are jobs that no one really asked to kill. AI is killing writing, music, art, and coding. I've done all of these voluntarily because I simply enjoyed them Meanwhile the parts of my existence that I actually hate - dealing with customer support, handling government forms, dealing with taxes - is far from being automated by AI Look at Suno. Fantastic tool, but where was the…

Its not a misallocation of capital its an investment in media control. You don't how all this works yet do you? Your job is to be frustrated and desperate so you indulge in vice and convenience so others can profit while making your confines smaller and smaller.

Re: AI Will Be Met with Violence, and Nothing Good Will Come of It

#16

The worst part is that AI's first casualties are jobs that no one really asked to kill. AI is killing writing, music, art, and coding. I've done all of these voluntarily because I simply enjoyed them Meanwhile the parts of my existence that I actually hate - dealing with customer support, handling government forms, dealing with taxes - is far from being automated by AI Look at Suno. Fantastic tool, but where was the…

imagine if producing music was as easy as using claude code or something

Re: AI Will Be Met with Violence, and Nothing Good Will Come of It

#19

This is nonsense, promoted to top of front page without any comments. How about all the rock stars killed over the years, or grocery store clerks shot and stabbed to death? EVERYTHING is met with violence because that's the nature of aggression no matter the impetus, it doesn't require a justifiable reason, only belief in the outcome of its use. Sam Altman having a Molotov cocktail thrown at his house after Ronan wro…

>How about all the rock stars killed over the years

With the exception of rappers, most musicians who die early die from overdoses, suicides, and such (the "27 club" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/27_Club>), as opposed to being murdered.

Re: AI Will Be Met with Violence, and Nothing Good Will Come of It

#20
post #2

> Every time I hear from Amodei or Altman that I could lose my job, I don’t think “oh, ok, then allow me pay you $20/month so that I can adapt to these uncertain times that have fallen upon my destiny by chance.” I think: “you, for fuck’s sake, you are doing this.” And I consider myself a pretty levelheaded guy, so imagine what not-so-levelheaded people think. Conversely, The Loudest Alarm Is Probably False[0]. If th…

Especially considering Amodei and Altman will be little more than footnotes in 50 years time. They seem important now but they are just the people that happened to be in charge at the moment AI happened to happen. There is more going on than a couple of billionaires taking your job away.
Post reply on HN