Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: The Musical Manifold [pdf]

esenbilproductions.replit.app

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

1–5 of 5 posts

Re: Show HN: The Musical Manifold [pdf]

#3

Post by Rochus »

Nice figures, but actually just a presentation, not a theory. Apparently based on this book: https://bookerapp.replit.app/book/fom, which neither seems to actually explain much. I agree that a better music theory is needed and that the manifold approach might work for music as well, but not much so far besides a few keywords and high-level ideas.

Re: Show HN: The Musical Manifold [pdf]

#4

Post by ersinesen »

Rochus wrote: post #3

Nice figures, but actually just a presentation, not a theory. Apparently based on this book: https://bookerapp.replit.app/book/fom , which neither seems to actually explain much. I agree that a better music theory is needed and that the manifold approach might work for music as well, but not much so far besides a few keywords and high-level ideas.

it is an attempt to lay the foundations. to me that foundation enables understanding complex concepts without adhoc narratives.
Post reply on HN