Live data from Hacker News

Microsoft PhotoDNA scanning problem

elevenforum.com

11–20 of 49 posts

Re: Microsoft PhotoDNA scanning problem

#12
post #5

> Microsoft's PhotoDNA scanning is not just in OneDrive, through the Microsoft's eco-system. Basically, if you are using your Microsoft account to sign in to Windows 11, PhotoDNA scans your entire computer. This information came directly from Microsoft Support. This sounds like a horrible privacy violation. Is it true? What do they do if they find a match?

According to the post, they called the police (!)

Re: Microsoft PhotoDNA scanning problem

#14
> Microsoft wanted me to confirm my age, that I was a "real person" along with identity. So Microsoft somehow reached out to the police department, based on my address information in my Microsoft accounts, with a check of some kind. I had to go to the local police department to verify who I was and my age. The police department told me it was odd. They are just following up on Microsoft complaint. This happened a few or so years ago. Microsoft confirmed my identity then. However, the Microsoft account profile photo issue still exists today.

You what now???

Re: Microsoft PhotoDNA scanning problem

#15

> I just do not know what to about it any longer. Each time I create a new Microsoft account There’s your problem. Don’t create a Microsoft account? Why would you need one anyway? To use windows? Why? Get Linux or switch to Mac.

"My picture gets a call to the police if I use it at my day job" is a hell of a sentence, for example.

Re: Microsoft PhotoDNA scanning problem

#16
post #9

Wait, reading between the lines it thinks his face is CSAM? I guess its a hash collision, but that is pretty crazy. Sounds like the plot to a scifi dystopia.

The perceptual hashes used for this kind of thing are, necessarily, much more susceptible to collisions than cryptographic hashes - so it's not out of the question at all.

Re: Microsoft PhotoDNA scanning problem

#17
post #9

Wait, reading between the lines it thinks his face is CSAM? I guess its a hash collision, but that is pretty crazy. Sounds like the plot to a scifi dystopia.

No, TFA says the picture was associated to an old account that got flagged - presumably anything linked to that account, picture included, is now cursed.

Re: Microsoft PhotoDNA scanning problem

#19

> I just do not know what to about it any longer. Each time I create a new Microsoft account There’s your problem. Don’t create a Microsoft account? Why would you need one anyway? To use windows? Why? Get Linux or switch to Mac.

"My picture gets a call to the police if I use it at my day job" is a hell of a sentence, for example.

[deleted]

Re: Microsoft PhotoDNA scanning problem

#20

> Microsoft wanted me to confirm my age, that I was a "real person" along with identity. So Microsoft somehow reached out to the police department, based on my address information in my Microsoft accounts, with a check of some kind. I had to go to the local police department to verify who I was and my age. The police department told me it was odd. They are just following up on Microsoft complaint. This happened a few…

> The police department told me it was odd. They are just following up on Microsoft complaint.

Since when does your local police department respond to a "Microsoft complaint?"

Post reply on HN