Live data from Hacker News

EFF is leaving X

eff.org

121–130 of 1001 posts

Re: EFF is leaving X

#122
post #107

If they justify it in terms of reach and impressions then say they will still be on BlueSky and Mastodon then you know it's purely ideological. Which is fine but just be honest about it.

The article is honest and open about reasons. What is dishonest is to write as if there was something wrong with leaving twittwr for "ideological" reasons.

Citing low engagement numbers as a reason for leaving while continuing to maintain an active Threads account is the opposite of honest.

Re: EFF is leaving X

#123
post #58

I don't understand, does it cost them something to copy/paste their posts to X?

Brand reputation. Every brand that chooses to use X implicitly supports X, even if they're not verified & paying X money.

Does anyone seriously think EFF posting to X yesterday tarnished their brand? Be real.

Re: EFF is leaving X

#124

That statement pretty clearly shows that they have certain ideological concerns that they value more highly than the kind of stuff we tend to think the EFF primarily cares about (digital privacy, open source, patent trolling, etc). Through that lens, I guess it makes sense that they see TikTok, Instagram, and BlueSky as worth their time and presence but not X.

[deleted]

Re: EFF is leaving X

#125

[flagged]

This is to laughably misguided that it leans toward malicious. I mean, you're talking about Elon, the Doge guy, the one who organized mass hoovering of citizens data from whatever sources he could get his grubby mitts on? That Elon? Opposed to mass surveillance?? And then you sprinkle some commonly known truths on top to make your comment palatable ("we're being divided and conquered!"), and finally you add a dash of…

It is malicious, and you shouldn’t be downvoted for calling out someone who is so obviously arguing in bad faith.

Re: EFF is leaving X

#127
post #114

I closed my X account Tuesday evening after the US-Iran ceasefire was announced. Something just snapped finally and I realized there’s no value in monitoring the situation and all these accounts are just monetizing my energy and attention with no value provided. The only social media I’m going to keep for now is Reddit and YouTube because I think it’s still a net positive for the educational content, but even those a…

You're keeping Reddit of all places? If you want a net win for attention and value, Reddit ain't it.

Reddit is a lot of different things and places. Some subreddit are basically PhpBB forums of old. Though now that discord seemingly took over, most of the closed communities i was part of went there, i don't think i connect more than once a month on average.

Re: EFF is leaving X

#128

[flagged]

Just to clarify, until recently you were under the impression that the political advocacy organization you donated to had no political opinions of their own?

GP is complaining about a shift from one set of positions to a different set.

Re: EFF is leaving X

#129

[flagged]

In a two party world where one of those parties has been captured by a fascist movement, there is no "political neutrality". You're either pro-fascist or anti-fascist. And if you care about rights at all, including free speech, then the correct alignment is anti-fascist.

And yes, this is a US centric comment. The EFF is a US based organization and the center of gravity of the tech world they deal with is in the US.

Re: EFF is leaving X

#130

If they justify it in terms of reach and impressions then say they will still be on BlueSky and Mastodon then you know it's purely ideological. Which is fine but just be honest about it.

Their front page says "The leading nonprofit defending digital privacy, free speech, and innovation for 35 years and counting!"

They are an organization that exists to support an ideological viewpoint. Any political stance is ideological!

Post reply on HN