Live data from Hacker News

Help Keep Thunderbird Alive

updates.thunderbird.net

41–50 of 403 posts

Re: Help Keep Thunderbird Alive

#44

Just donated. Have been using Thunderbird for years. I once donated to Wikipedia - and they have billions I heard - so might as well donate to another important piece of software for my digital life. Now that I read the comments I find out Mozilla might have enough money and a CEO taking in millions. Any recommendations for a good email client on Linux? Just as a backup for now...

Mozilla and Mozla are two different corporations though both under the mozilla foundation.

Re: Help Keep Thunderbird Alive

#45
post #17

If you press the browser’s back button on the donation page, they send you to a page pestering you for your email address so they can send you a reminder to donate later. Talk about a dark pattern. Mozilla has really gone off the rails. An organisation who claims to work on behalf of the user and who makes a web browser, actively hijacking the user experience to peddle for a few dollars? Why the heck is Thunderbird “…

LibreWolf should have no reason to exist. It does because Mozilla’s values are largely marketing.

Re: Help Keep Thunderbird Alive

#46

Just donated. Have been using Thunderbird for years. I once donated to Wikipedia - and they have billions I heard - so might as well donate to another important piece of software for my digital life. Now that I read the comments I find out Mozilla might have enough money and a CEO taking in millions. Any recommendations for a good email client on Linux? Just as a backup for now...

Mozilla Corporation may have enough money, but they don't develop Thunderbird. If you used the donation form on this page, you didn't donate to Mozilla Corporation, but to the company developing Thunderbird. So all is fine.

Re: Help Keep Thunderbird Alive

#47
After reading a bunch of negative comments here, let me add a little on the bright side. I've been using Thunderbird for many years, currently both at home and at work to manage gmail accounts, pop at home, imap in the office. It works great for me, with a few annoyances but nothing serious.

As for the donations, Thunderbird seems to be somehow apart from Mozilla now, so I don't think much about specific org structure and will gladly donate.

Maybe on paper there're dozens of alternatives, but when I consider my specific requirements, I haven't found anything better, YMMV.

Re: Help Keep Thunderbird Alive

#48
post #17

If you press the browser’s back button on the donation page, they send you to a page pestering you for your email address so they can send you a reminder to donate later. Talk about a dark pattern. Mozilla has really gone off the rails. An organisation who claims to work on behalf of the user and who makes a web browser, actively hijacking the user experience to peddle for a few dollars? Why the heck is Thunderbird “…

> Where do the billions of dollars from Google go?

They go to the Mozilla Corporation: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mozilla_Corporation#Finances

The Mozilla Corporation then picks and chooses what it finances within the Mozilla Foundation. Their financial statements don't break down how they spend on software development within the Foundation, it only lists out employee salaries, specific directors' salaries and grants to outsiders... but it would seem Thunderbird doesn't get much if they're out begging.

https://stateof.mozilla.org/pdf/Mozilla%20Fdn%202024%20-%20A...

So, as an example, in 2024, it got:

- $498,218,000 from royalties (e.g. Google)

- $66,396,000 from paid services (e.g Pocket, VPN) and advertisers

- $15,782,000 from donations

And it spent:

- $290,448,000 on programmer salaries

- $163,516,000 on manager salaries

- $36,358,000 on servers, cloud, etc.

- $20,258,000 on consultants (e.g. branding consultants)

- $9,573,000 on travel

- $2,192,000 on grants and fellowships

So overall, it didn't spent that much on the stupid doomed side projects! It spent a lot more on flying managers and marketing consultants to nice soirees.

But the real question, not answered by this financial report, is how much programming labour was spent on Thunderbird, versus other Mozilla projects?

Re: Help Keep Thunderbird Alive

#49
post #17

If you press the browser’s back button on the donation page, they send you to a page pestering you for your email address so they can send you a reminder to donate later. Talk about a dark pattern. Mozilla has really gone off the rails. An organisation who claims to work on behalf of the user and who makes a web browser, actively hijacking the user experience to peddle for a few dollars? Why the heck is Thunderbird “…

I don't think it's a dark pattern. Just a common marketing thing. Not "everything that annoys me" is a dark pattern.

Re: Help Keep Thunderbird Alive

#50
post #5

Mozilla brings in almost $700 million per year, they have more than enough money to sponsor MZLA/Thunderbird development.

What do they do with all that money? According to wikipedia, they had about 750 employees. That's a lot of employees for the amount of useful products they have.
Post reply on HN