Live data from Hacker News

LibreOffice – Let's put an end to the speculation

blog.documentfoundation.org

101–110 of 139 posts

Re: LibreOffice – Let's put an end to the speculation

#101

I'm not following this, but having drama in an office suite dev team sounds funny to me. I just want to open an occasional word doc and sometimes make a spreadsheet.

A lot of open source software has drama so it isn't surprising to me.

To be fair, closed source office suites also have drama. Did you know the VP who was responsible for the Office ribbon is in the Epstein files?

Re: LibreOffice – Let's put an end to the speculation

#103
post #39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Before Libre Office was Open Office. I take comfort that we would not be without a local office suite for long.

I’d love for someone to be able to take it from “yeah it mostly works for me” to “oh fuck you Microsoft, I’m going to move our entire company over to this”. I’m not going to hold my breath.

Boggles the mind that corporates stick to expensive, inefficient, insecure and in so many ways crap software. SQL Sever, Office, Oracle (any product), Windows servers and workstations - yet demand peak efficiency from staff.

Re: LibreOffice – Let's put an end to the speculation

#104
Michael Meek’s referenced blog post. The irony is I remember him championing openness for OpenOffice and I remember how transparent he was when he helped found libreoffice and TDF. What a shame we have devolved to this situation.

https://www.collaboraonline.com/blog/tdf-ejects-its-core-dev...

Re: LibreOffice – Let's put an end to the speculation

#106
Heck I hope this doesn't result in a bug fork happening; it's already a PITA to deal with fixing bugs that have been inherited from OOo bug trackers or earlier. You hit things like wanting to test against a file that used to be in a long dead bug tracker.

Re: LibreOffice – Let's put an end to the speculation

#107

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think such situations are rather big risk that a community that already wasn't very active atrophies or splits and then atrophies. With code bases like that there's also a lot of maintenance so being able to run an old version is not necessarily enough.

What maintenance are you talking about? I'm quite sure I could open any document on my computer with a libreoffice version from ten years ago. The functionality doesn't magically rot away...

Security vulnerabilities for one obvious example

Re: LibreOffice – Let's put an end to the speculation

#108
post #51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Isn't this theft, if true?

I wouldn't call it theft, exactly. Presumably work did get done. If I'm reading it right, its just a terrible conflict of interest. The board uses donations to pay companies to work on LibreOffice. That seems totally fine. Some of the board were running/part of companies that rely and work on LibreOffice. That also seems mostly fine? You want your board to represent your community. Then, those same board members dire…

> It doesn't seem that is really what the foundation is arguing though, so I'm guessing it wasn't that bad. It seems more their argument is that this violates the non-profit laws they operate under.

It may have been that bad. They don't really have to get into the messy arguments of "was this a fair price for this kind of contracting" because that kind of arrangement is inherently unethical, to the point that you can kind of assume it's embezzlement by default (which is why those non-profit laws are set that way).

Re: LibreOffice – Let's put an end to the speculation

#109

I wish this was more clearly written. Maybe I missed something, and I guess this is supposing the reader already has a lot of background, but there are several points that confused me. "At the time, nobody could imagine that the companies that had supported OpenOffice.org until then would create a project to kill LibreOffice." Did they mean... to kill OpenOffice? Or had supported LibreOffice would want to create a pr…

Yes. I am bookmarking it for future reference. The post shows a perfect example why you need marketing and PR agency.
Post reply on HN