Live data from Hacker News

The Subprime AI Crisis Is Here

wheresyoured.at

1–10 of 28 posts

Re: The Subprime AI Crisis Is Here

#2
I would respect Ed (and Gary Marcus) more if they would concede the occasional point. But everything AI is always a hyperbolic and unqualified disaster. I suppose that's what the audience wants.

"every bit of AI demand ... that exists only exists due to subsidies"

Really? NOBODY would pay whatever the fully-loaded cost is? What about people running local models on their own GPUs? Are they being subsidized too?

Re: The Subprime AI Crisis Is Here

#5
post #2

I would respect Ed (and Gary Marcus) more if they would concede the occasional point. But everything AI is always a hyperbolic and unqualified disaster. I suppose that's what the audience wants. "every bit of AI demand ... that exists only exists due to subsidies" Really? NOBODY would pay whatever the fully-loaded cost is? What about people running local models on their own GPUs? Are they being subsidized too?

> Are they being subsidized too?

Yes, because they didn't pay the cost to train those models in the first place.

Re: The Subprime AI Crisis Is Here

#6
post #2

I would respect Ed (and Gary Marcus) more if they would concede the occasional point. But everything AI is always a hyperbolic and unqualified disaster. I suppose that's what the audience wants. "every bit of AI demand ... that exists only exists due to subsidies" Really? NOBODY would pay whatever the fully-loaded cost is? What about people running local models on their own GPUs? Are they being subsidized too?

> Are they being subsidized too? Yes, because they didn't pay the cost to train those models in the first place.

True, good point. I still think the piece goes too far with its claims.

Re: The Subprime AI Crisis Is Here

#7
LLMs are capable and able to produce value. There's no questioning that - anyone who says otherwise is in absolute denial.

The problem is.... the amount invested makes zero sense and the returns needed to justify the valuations of these firms won't come.

The players in the Tech industry in general have gotten way too ahead of themselves. When this all settles the big danger for MSFT, Google, Meta etc is that investors will trust them with the cash on the balance sheet less - demanding more cash return. Apple will come through this period very strong and end up looking like they played a genius move keeping out of it.

Re: The Subprime AI Crisis Is Here

#8
Endgame is IPOing those AI companies and getting them on indexes, forcing index funds to buy them, which seemed to be evergreen investment category, but I’m not so sure anymore..

Did somebody say crypto?

Re: The Subprime AI Crisis Is Here

#10
Great writeup. Only thing I din't see in here was an analysis of the impact of players like Talaas[1] and their stupid faster hardware LLMs.

I feel like it could be majorly disruptive, but idk if it's going to prolong the apocalypse or bring it about sooner -- or if it's a big nothing burger.

But the demo[2] is super cool.

[1]: https://taalas.com

[2]: https://chatjimmy.ai/

Post reply on HN