Live data from Hacker News

Jury finds Meta liable in case over child sexual exploitation on its platforms

cnn.com

121–130 of 579 posts

Re: Jury finds Meta liable in case over child sexual exploitation on its platforms

#121
post #108

Maybe I'm just getting old and cynical but, while I think current social media is bad for children, I'm very suspicious of the current international agreement that it's time to take action, especially with all the ID verification coming from multiple avenues

Governments always want censorship and speech control. That never changes. The only difference is that now the general populace has accumulated enough disgruntlement to social media to be used against themselves.

Re: Jury finds Meta liable in case over child sexual exploitation on its platforms

#125
post #108

Maybe I'm just getting old and cynical but, while I think current social media is bad for children, I'm very suspicious of the current international agreement that it's time to take action, especially with all the ID verification coming from multiple avenues

A lot of the ID verification stuff is coming FROM those companies

Re: Jury finds Meta liable in case over child sexual exploitation on its platforms

#127
post #108

Maybe I'm just getting old and cynical but, while I think current social media is bad for children, I'm very suspicious of the current international agreement that it's time to take action, especially with all the ID verification coming from multiple avenues

Governments always want censorship and speech control. That never changes. The only difference is that now the general populace has accumulated enough disgruntlement to social media to be used against themselves.

No the difference is that when governments are still constrained by the rule of law it’s cheap PR to fight the government on data access claims but once they are authoritarian fascist industrialists fall over themselves to feed everything into Palantir

Re: Jury finds Meta liable in case over child sexual exploitation on its platforms

#128
This particular verdict is a long time coming. How it drives meaningful change is the bigger question.

One of the challenges we need to resolve is the race to the bottom for online communities - engagement metrics will always result in a PH level that supports more acerbic behavior.

There’s multiple analyses that you can find, if not your own experience, to believe that we should be able to do better with our information commons.

Just today, I found a paper that studied a corpus of Twitter discussions and found that bad-faith interactions constituted 68.3% of all replies (Twitter data).

The engineer and analyst side of us will always question these types of analyses.

I’ve read enough papers at this point for the methods to matter more than the conclusion.

1) meta, and the other tech platforms need to open up their research and data. NDAs and business incentives prevent us from having the boring technical conversations.

2) tech needs someone else to be the bogeyman - the way we did for tobacco. The profit incentive ensures profitable predatory features pass review. Expecting firms to ignore quarterly shareholder reviews for warm fuzzies is … setting ourselves up for failure.

Regulators (with teeth) need to be propped up so that the right amount of predictable friction (liability) is introduced.

3) tech firms need an opportunity or forum to come clean. The sheer gap between the practical reality of something like content moderation vs the ignorance of users and regulators - results in surprise and outrage when people find out how the sausage is made.

4) algorithm defaults decide the median experience for participants in our shred market place of ideas. The defaults need to be set in a manner that works for humans and society (whatever that might be).

Economies are systems to align incentives to achieve subjective goals.

Re: Jury finds Meta liable in case over child sexual exploitation on its platforms

#129
post #108

Maybe I'm just getting old and cynical but, while I think current social media is bad for children, I'm very suspicious of the current international agreement that it's time to take action, especially with all the ID verification coming from multiple avenues

[deleted]

Re: Jury finds Meta liable in case over child sexual exploitation on its platforms

#130
post #108

Maybe I'm just getting old and cynical but, while I think current social media is bad for children, I'm very suspicious of the current international agreement that it's time to take action, especially with all the ID verification coming from multiple avenues

because it is a false dilemma
Post reply on HN