Live data from Hacker News

Why was an Indian man held for sending a tweet?

bbc.co.uk

11–20 of 46 posts

Re: Why was an Indian man held for sending a tweet?

#13

Maybe the headline should be "Why were 2 men arrested and convicted for tweeting in the UK?"

Actually, it was for creating a Facebook event. Arguably even more private. http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2011/aug/16/facebook-riot-calls...

Eh, the story there isn't really anything to do with social media. It's about riot-related crimes being treated more harshly.

Re: Why was an Indian man held for sending a tweet?

#14
post #12

because India is a corrupt mafia run state?

Corrupt, yes. Mafia-run, no. There are limits to the insults we will take.

Come to think of it, implying that some of our politicians were smart enough to be mafia would be highly insulting to the mafia.

Some are wannabe mafia, though. They're the ones we try to avoid. The others are corrupt, but often their motives are fairly aligned with public interest. For instance, they take cuts on all infrastructure projects, so our infrastructure tends to improve at a fairly good pace - though obviously not as fast as it theoretically could.

Re: Why was an Indian man held for sending a tweet?

#17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Actually, it was for creating a Facebook event. Arguably even more private. http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2011/aug/16/facebook-riot-calls...

Eh, the story there isn't really anything to do with social media. It's about riot-related crimes being treated more harshly.

But, the rioting there never happened. It only ever got as far as a Facebook event, seen only by their own friends. (And a friend of a friend, who obviously panicked a little)

Re: Why was an Indian man held for sending a tweet?

#19

because India is a corrupt mafia run state?

If you were from India, you could also face jail. Why you insult the mafia by comparing these politicians (Indian). Mafia also have limit for earning money but if you just read the amount of fraud / corruption in last 5-6 yrs of ruling Congress party, no one can even imaging, India is a poor & developing county.
Post reply on HN