Live data from Hacker News

4Chan mocks £520k fine for UK online safety breaches

bbc.com

21–30 of 936 posts

Re: 4Chan mocks £520k fine for UK online safety breaches

#21
post #10
post #4

> "Companies – wherever they're based – are not allowed to sell unsafe toys to children in the UK. And society has long protected youngsters from things like alcohol, smoking and gambling. The digital world should be no different," she said. So the UK plans to fine Parisian bars that serve alcohol to British under-18s in France on holiday?

In theory the children are committing a crime yes, but obviously enforcement is extremely low; left mainly to their teachers. I don't think UK law governs foreign companies' overseas operations based on the nationality of the customer though, no.

[deleted]

Re: 4Chan mocks £520k fine for UK online safety breaches

#22
>However, a lawyer representing the company - which has previously said it won't pay such fines - has responded to the demand with an AI-generated cartoon image of a hamster.

>The latest image is not the first picture of a hamster lawyers for 4chan have sent in reply to Ofcom

amazing. same energy as the pirate bay telling dreamworks to sodomize themselves. i cant help but laugh at the absurdness of it.

Re: 4Chan mocks £520k fine for UK online safety breaches

#23
Meanwhile Google.com shows all manner of depravity if you click “safe search: off”.

I realize there’s a carve out in the legislation for search engines but if the goal is to stop little Timmy finding pictures of an X being Yd up the Z then it is a resolute failure.

The only thing that works with children is transparency and accountability, be that the school firewall or a ban on screen use in secret.

”screens where I can see ‘em!”

Re: 4Chan mocks £520k fine for UK online safety breaches

#24
post #10
post #4

> "Companies – wherever they're based – are not allowed to sell unsafe toys to children in the UK. And society has long protected youngsters from things like alcohol, smoking and gambling. The digital world should be no different," she said. So the UK plans to fine Parisian bars that serve alcohol to British under-18s in France on holiday?

In theory the children are committing a crime yes, but obviously enforcement is extremely low; left mainly to their teachers. I don't think UK law governs foreign companies' overseas operations based on the nationality of the customer though, no.

They’re not breaking any law.

Laws apply to actions in the country, they’re not based on citizenship.

If you go to Amsterdam and sleep with a hooker, you didn’t break a law by doing that: despite prostitution (specifically purchasing sex) being illegal in many western countries.

Re: 4Chan mocks £520k fine for UK online safety breaches

#26
post #7
post #4

> "Companies – wherever they're based – are not allowed to sell unsafe toys to children in the UK. And society has long protected youngsters from things like alcohol, smoking and gambling. The digital world should be no different," she said. So the UK plans to fine Parisian bars that serve alcohol to British under-18s in France on holiday?

This is more like the UK fining Parisian bars that courier alcohol to under-18s in the UK .

It’s a lot more like banning the importation of books and newspapers that the government doesn’t agree with…

Re: 4Chan mocks £520k fine for UK online safety breaches

#30
post #11

People used to tell kids to not go to a shady part of town while they spent their afternoons outside unsupervised. Can parents not tell kids to not go to certain websites? We still went to the shady part of town and the kids will still go to 4chan but at least we don't need to give away freedoms. Such erosion of freedom for the common person because parents can't have an awkward conversation is irritating.

Do you have children?

I do. I also grew up on 4chan because I didn’t have an involved parent, and I lived in the suburbs where finding friends to just “go outside and play” wasn’t an option. Consuming that content was genuinely hurtful and probably forever altered my psyche. I have the means and knowledge, in technical skill and life experience, to know how these things work, and protect my kids from that. Most people don’t.
Post reply on HN