Live data from Hacker News

Astral to Join OpenAI

astral.sh

41–50 of 951 posts

Re: Astral to Join OpenAI

#41
post #17

As a non python dev I really thought UV and TY are great tools and liked their approaches but I don't know how good it is that they are privately held... no a fan

Technically the tools are not privately held, they're OSS with a permissive licence. It's just that the bulk of work was done by them. The acquisition (ostensibly) changes none of that

Re: Astral to Join OpenAI

#44

If you don't pay for your tools and support OSS financially, this is what happens. Although Astral being VC funded was already headed this way anyway. Deno, Pydantic (Both Sequoia) will go the same way as with many other VC backed "open source" dev tools. It will go towards AI companies buying up the very same tools, putting it in their next model update and used against you. Rented back to you for $20/mo.

There is nothing wrong with big money backing, often is necessary for long term bets, but rug pulling is a serious threat. VC funded open source has become a pattern/playbook.

Re: Astral to Join OpenAI

#45

This is a serious risk for the open source ecosystem and particularly the scientific ecosystem that over the last years has adopted many of these technologies. Having their future depend on a cap-ex heavy company that is currently (based on reporting) spending approx. 2.5 dollars to make a dollar of revenue and must have hypergrowth in the next years or perish is less than ideal. This should discourage anybody doing…

I don't know how to search for that report, can you share it?

Re: Astral to Join OpenAI

#46

This is a serious risk for the open source ecosystem and particularly the scientific ecosystem that over the last years has adopted many of these technologies. Having their future depend on a cap-ex heavy company that is currently (based on reporting) spending approx. 2.5 dollars to make a dollar of revenue and must have hypergrowth in the next years or perish is less than ideal. This should discourage anybody doing…

Would single maintainers of critical open source projects be a better situation?

Re: Astral to Join OpenAI

#48

Company that repeatedly tells you software developers are obsoleted by their product buys more software developers instead of using said product to create software. Hmm.

As good as the team is, that's not what they're buying in this case.

Re: Astral to Join OpenAI

#50
post #4

Woah, first Anthropic buys Bun, now OpenAI Astral? Seems like the big AI players love buying up the good dev tooling companies. I hope this means the Astral folks can keep doing what they are doing, because I absolutely love uv (ruff is pretty nice too).

>Seems like the big AI players love buying up the good dev tooling companies. Would be a good mustache-twirling cartoon villain tactics, you know, try to prevent advances in developer experience to make vibecoding more attractive =)

You know it's absolutely going that way. That's the lifecycle of corporate strategy.
Post reply on HN