Live data from Hacker News

Malus – Clean Room as a Service

malus.sh

61–70 of 566 posts

Re: Malus – Clean Room as a Service

#61
As a hypothetical.

Let’s say instead it consolidated a few packages into 1. This might even be a good idea for security reasons.

Then it offered a mandatory 15% revenue tip to the original projects.

So far GPL enforcement usually comes down to “umm, try and sue us lol”.

How much human intervention is needed for it to be a real innovation and not llm generated. Can I someone to watch Claude do its thing and press enter 3 times ?

Re: Malus – Clean Room as a Service

#63
I know this is satire, but I have an adjacent problem I could use help with. In my company, we have some legacy apps that run, but we no longer have the source, any everyone that worked on them has probably left the planet.

We need to replatform them at some point, and ideally I'd like to let some agents "use" the apps as a means to copy them / rebuild. Most of these are desktop apps, but some have browser interfaces. Has anyone tried something like this or can recommend a service that's worked for them?

Re: Malus – Clean Room as a Service

#65
post #2

is the motto, "Don't be good?"

"I solemnly swear that I am up to no good" and their seal is ⍼.

https://www.hp-lexicon.org/magic/solemnly-swear-no-good/

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47329605

https://www.explainxkcd.com/wiki/index.php/2606:_Weird_Unico...

Re: Malus – Clean Room as a Service

#66

I know this is satire, but I have an adjacent problem I could use help with. In my company, we have some legacy apps that run, but we no longer have the source, any everyone that worked on them has probably left the planet. We need to replatform them at some point, and ideally I'd like to let some agents "use" the apps as a means to copy them / rebuild. Most of these are desktop apps, but some have browser interfaces…

Interested to keep updated on this point. As a consultant, I've worked on transformation of legacy applications so this would help me greatly as well. We've worked on pretty archaic systems where no one knows how the system works even if we have the source code.

Re: Malus – Clean Room as a Service

#67

This is satire but this is where things are heading. The impact on the OSS ecosystem is probably not a net positive overall, but don't forget that this also applies to commercial software as well. There will be many questions asked, like why buy some SaaS with way too many features when you can just reimplement the parts you need? Why buy some expensive software package when you can point the LLM into the binary with…

[deleted]

Re: Malus – Clean Room as a Service

#69
post #14

> You have been so generous, so unreasonably, almost suspiciously generous, that you have made it possible for an entire global economy to run on software that nobody technically owns, maintained by people that nobody technically employs, governed by licenses that nobody technically reads. It is a miracle of human cooperation. It is also, from a fiduciary standpoint, completely insane. Funny but true.

It's funny that humans working together for mutual benefit via any other mechanism than regimented corporate slavery is considered insane.

Easily explained by the fact that writing some types of software and seeing people using it is fun. Some people take photos for free also.

Doesn’t apply everywhere though.

Re: Malus – Clean Room as a Service

#70

As a hypothetical. Let’s say instead it consolidated a few packages into 1. This might even be a good idea for security reasons. Then it offered a mandatory 15% revenue tip to the original projects. So far GPL enforcement usually comes down to “umm, try and sue us lol”. How much human intervention is needed for it to be a real innovation and not llm generated. Can I someone to watch Claude do its thing and press ente…

If the AI could do good refactor of OS project, remove unused code/features and make the code more efficient. Than we really would be out of jobs :D
Post reply on HN