Live data from Hacker News

Moot.it: Forums and commenting re-imagined

moot.it

11–20 of 61 posts

Re: Moot.it: Forums and commenting re-imagined

#12

The concept of internet forums has mostly been gathering dust for the past ten years while the ways people discuss over the internet have changed profoundly, so some re-imagining is definitely in order.

indeed. this particular service looks good, but reimagining is a strong word for what they've done if the screen shots are anything to go by.

Theres a link to a demo on the bottom to play with it.

Re: Moot.it: Forums and commenting re-imagined

#13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How is it free?

My guess is they are cookie-ing browsers and doing data collection/retargeting.

If they do that, they have to be careful about countries that have data protection / privacy rights, and they might have to be careful about signing up companies/sites hosted in these countries, specifically, the EU

Re: Moot.it: Forums and commenting re-imagined

#14

Is this related to the Moot?

Doesn't look like it, but quite a silly name choice for a product around online discussions.

Moot = verb (used with object) to present or introduce (any point, subject, project, etc.) for discussion.

http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/moot

Cannot think of a better domain name.

Re: Moot.it: Forums and commenting re-imagined

#15
I see it took some good ideas from Stackexchange. Good. Since there's no contact email, I'm writing questions here:

1. Is it configurable, to get rid of "likes" and other cluttering elements?

2. I'd like to pay for not tracking my users. Is this possible?

Re: Moot.it: Forums and commenting re-imagined

#16

Is this related to the Moot?

Doesn't look like it, but quite a silly name choice for a product around online discussions.

"Moot" is an Old English word for a meeting, which I believe is still in modern usage. I've heard it used at any rate. So not that bad a name really.

Re: Moot.it: Forums and commenting re-imagined

#17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How is it free?

My guess is they are cookie-ing browsers and doing data collection/retargeting.

None of that is taking place. SSO and some deeper private discussion options will be available for paid customers. Those options are not relevant for the vast majority of people that would use moot though.

Re: Moot.it: Forums and commenting re-imagined

#18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How is it free?

My guess is they are cookie-ing browsers and doing data collection/retargeting.

Absolutely not. We will never sell data and we hate ads.

In future we're going to charge for private posts.

Re: Moot.it: Forums and commenting re-imagined

#19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

indeed. this particular service looks good, but reimagining is a strong word for what they've done if the screen shots are anything to go by.

Theres a link to a demo on the bottom to play with it.

The link is so hidden I couldn't have discovered it without looking at the bottom (coincidentally).

Re: Moot.it: Forums and commenting re-imagined

#20

The concept of internet forums has mostly been gathering dust for the past ten years while the ways people discuss over the internet have changed profoundly, so some re-imagining is definitely in order.

Seems no one has made any real serious attempt to really modernize them.

Stack Exchange?
Post reply on HN