Live data from Hacker News

Windows 11 Notepad to support Markdown

blogs.windows.com

331–340 of 558 posts

Re: Windows 11 Notepad to support Markdown

#331
post #317

It doesn't support basic code/monospace blocks using backticks: > Unsupported Syntax Detected > This file contains syntax that isn't fully supported in formatted view. Some content may not render as intended, and switching views could modify parts of your original Markdown. Do you want to continue?

So custom implementation, then? How very Microsoft.

Re: Windows 11 Notepad to support Markdown

#332

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

> "adding rich text editing features to a text editor” Yeah, we already had that. In the form of Wordpad. Which was EOL'd. And now we have Notepad with AI features. Notepad was, and always should have been, a simple & lightweight text box for storing and editing text only files. If you wanted to edit something more complicated, you could use the other tool that was built into Windows specifically for that.

I like having something all in one.

Re: Windows 11 Notepad to support Markdown

#333

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Please show me the few sentence prompt to create a windows 10 level notepad.exe clone that I can quickly open and use by hitting win+r

[flagged]

lol calling Python lightweight:

  ⟩ dnf install --downloadonly --installroot /tmp/yourmom python3
  …SNIP…
  Transaction Summary:
  Installing:        59 packages

  Total size of inbound packages is 33 MiB. Need to download 33 MiB.
  After this operation, 118 MiB extra will be used (install 118 MiB, remove 0 B).
  The operation will only download packages for the transaction.

Don't get me wrong, Python is a great many things. Easy to use, surprisingly fast for a scripting language, and well documented. But not lightweight.

(( The Windows version is 110MiB after decompression. ))

Re: Windows 11 Notepad to support Markdown

#334

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's been so weird to watch over the decades as team sizes, budgets, and timelines have exploded even as we've abandoned once-normal things like native GUI applications as too hard in favor of "more efficient" webshit... even as the aforementioned stuff with growing team sizes, budgets, and timelines have happened.

What's weird is that AI is supposed to make development easy enough that native applications are just as fast to build than web apps Somehow in this timeline AI can only be used to make things worse and sloppier

The engineers running the AI have to still be good.

AI code that isn't properly guided and controlled by an engineer is just as sloppy as the human behind it.

AI is an accelerate for programming, but some developers create horrible code before AI, snd AI won't change that. It just lets them do it faster.

Re: Windows 11 Notepad to support Markdown

#336

I still say this is stupid AF, and that notepad should stay as simple as reasonable as a plain text editor and they should have resurrected "WordPad" for this purpose if they wanted it in Windows. I'm mixed on the enhancements to Paint... but this just feels a bit off. Maybe I'd mind it less if they put the new MS Edit in Windows by default, so again, there's a minimal plain text editor in the box.

The minimal text editor shipped with Windows is now Edit https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/edit/

I didn't remember that they'd shipped that. I remember reading about it but I ever tried it. My hot take, after 10 minutes, is that it's frustrating and not at all a replacement for Notepad. (Fortunately you can uninstall the shitty "Windows Notepad" and the real notepad.exe takes over.)

This new "Edit" is completely tone-deaf in that it doesn't keep the keybindings from Notepad (i.e. no CTRL-H for find/replace, no F5 for the current date/time). You can't turn off the status bar or the line numbers. It doesn't follow the OS theme (instead pretending to be a text-mode application). It tries to be "helpful" with indentation.

At least they bothered to get Find Next with F3 right.

It would have been immensely better if they'd just ported the old MS-DOS EDIT / QBASIC over to Windows.

Re: Windows 11 Notepad to support Markdown

#337

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> "adding rich text editing features to a text editor” Yeah, we already had that. In the form of Wordpad. Which was EOL'd. And now we have Notepad with AI features. Notepad was, and always should have been, a simple & lightweight text box for storing and editing text only files. If you wanted to edit something more complicated, you could use the other tool that was built into Windows specifically for that.

I like having something all in one.

I liked having a simple plain text editor

Re: Windows 11 Notepad to support Markdown

#338

Once upon a time, you could strip formatting from the clipboard in notepad with ^V ^A ^C, for example if you were trying to paste from edge into word. There's still a market for a non-rich text editor, without autosave, cloud, account login or AI.

Notepad in Windows 11 (while not autosave) will preserve unsaved documents.

Re: Windows 11 Notepad to support Markdown

#339

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Please show me the few sentence prompt to create a windows 10 level notepad.exe clone that I can quickly open and use by hitting win+r

I think Dave (of Dave's Garage) did this just a few months ago... I think there were some short-comings regarding wide character support (BoM detection, etc)... but it was pretty much a working Notepad.exe implementation. FWIW, you can also get the new Edit implementation that's built with Rust and the Windows exe is 250kb...

Thought of this immediately after reading the parent comment. I was actually pretty shocked at how seamless the whole project was.

Re: Windows 11 Notepad to support Markdown

#340
post #304

They’re turning Notepad into what Wordpad was (or was supposed to be). Now everyone looking for the light weightiest *.txt editor must find a new tool...

KDE's kate runs well on Windows. It can be installed easily via chocolatey.

It's also in winget
Post reply on HN