Live data from Hacker News

Windows 11 Notepad to support Markdown

blogs.windows.com

121–130 of 558 posts

Re: Windows 11 Notepad to support Markdown

#121
post #90

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well, at least they brought back edit[0] [0] https://github.com/microsoft/edit

If this was actually (pre)installed with Windows, I wouldn't mind the changes to notepad nearly as much.

While I'd love it installed by default, I still very much mind that they're ruining Notepad.

Plus this Markdown preview functionality just caused Notepad to have a Remote Code Execution Vulnerability in it.

Re: Windows 11 Notepad to support Markdown

#122

So the markup dialect that's widely used but suffers from a near-total lack of viewers will now finally be rendered as intended, at least on Windows? Markdown presents a chicken-&-egg scenario that has dragged on for decades: tons of Markdown documents, but almost nothing with which to simply view (not edit) them as intended. Mystifying.

At this point I really think GitHub should formally publish their flavor as well as a default implementation. It's likely the single most widely used variant online at this point. I know there are others and there are fine points. I would like to see a couple minor additions to support image placement (that aligns with Medium's editor) and finally a strike-through text notation. But that's about it.

Github does publish their spec: https://github.github.com/gfm/ The CommonMark spec is largely based on it.

Re: Windows 11 Notepad to support Markdown

#123

Earlier quoted context omitted.

while this is cool and I want to play with it myself, it's still sort of discounting the overhead here of installing python, installing tkinter, adding shortcuts to the program within Windows, etc. Of course the barrier to creating bespoke tools is lower but it's also still a decent bit of overhead and not just "hey AI, create me a Notepad clone that works like it used to". Arguably it's still more intensive than goo…

[flagged]

>Are you moving the goalpost?

I mean you did originally claim that this was something that was "for the masses" and then posted a solution that only someone technical could actually use.

Not that I doubt it couldn't one shot something this simple with a .exe wrapper.

Re: Windows 11 Notepad to support Markdown

#125
post #74

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Oh I’m well aware, I just think this reaction is ridiculous. Just make your own damn notepad if it bothers you lol.

> Just make your own damn notepad if it bothers you lol. If you use many different machines throughout your workday, this means you have to carry a copy of your bespoke solution with you on a memory stick or something, and hope that the machine you want to use it on allows the use of memory sticks or unapproved software. It's far better to use an application that you can count on already existing on the machines.

TBF, a lot of people used to keep portable apps like this... then IT started locking down even being able to mount a USB storage device. I used to do this for my email and mail profile with a portable Thunderbird.

I even worked on an app in a relatively secure environment where the work around for an early SPA and IE6-8 company wide, was for the systems analysts using our app to use a portable firefox browser on the user desktop. IE6-8 in particular were really bad when you had an SPA as you had events tied to dom elements across the COM bridge that wouldn't release unless all dom and script references were freed up. jQuery actually did this, if you managed everything through it, but our app was an early version of extjs... so after 3-4 hours it would just run out of memory and die.

Re: Windows 11 Notepad to support Markdown

#126

I still say this is stupid AF, and that notepad should stay as simple as reasonable as a plain text editor and they should have resurrected "WordPad" for this purpose if they wanted it in Windows. I'm mixed on the enhancements to Paint... but this just feels a bit off. Maybe I'd mind it less if they put the new MS Edit in Windows by default, so again, there's a minimal plain text editor in the box.

I was an engineer on the Visual Studio team. Internally, the Notepad project existed to provide a minimal, shippable product that we could use as a testbed. We used it to validate everything from compiler changes to kernel32 loader behavior on beta versions of Windows. If Notepad didn’t run, your feature didn’t work.

This doesn't seem like a good idea.

Re: Windows 11 Notepad to support Markdown

#127

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Can Microsoft please stop? If I need Copilot and Markdown Support I use VS Code or any other software that supports it. I can't even get visual studio code to stop showing that right-hand sidebar every time it opens up, regardless of what settings I use. It seems to work for a while, and then it appears again like magic. I'm not sure how many more times they have to hit you straight in the face before you realize y…

have you tried adding this to your settings json? workbench.secondarySideBar.defaultVisibility": "hidden",

It's still annoying to have it by default even if you do make use of it.

Re: Windows 11 Notepad to support Markdown

#128
Yes. Supports .md but when you try to save back to .txt it does something to line endings that you cannot see in notepad but if you grep your .txt files from wsl like, I do all the time, you get page long strings instead of matching lines. It's weird and I haven't dug into the cause as it was easier to save as a new note but pretty sukky for an IT company to miss something like that.

Re: Windows 11 Notepad to support Markdown

#129
post #56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's fashionable to hate on anything Windows. Especially in tech circles.

Oh I’m well aware, I just think this reaction is ridiculous. Just make your own damn notepad if it bothers you lol.

We used to have a perfectly good application that came with the OS. Then Microsoft ruined it. Yes I can make my own Notepad, but I shouldn't have to. If Microsoft really wanted a built-in text editor that had features Notepad didn't, they should've made a second application rather than ruining the minimalist one.
Post reply on HN