Live data from Hacker News

I'm not worried about AI job loss

davidoks.blog

11–20 of 582 posts

Re: I'm not worried about AI job loss

#11
post #7
post #2

Maybe you should be a little worried. A healthy fear never killed anyone.

"For quality of life, it is better to err on the side of being an optimist and wrong, rather than a pessimist and right." -Elon Musk

Optimism is a luxury for those who won't be the ones paying for the mistake.

Re: I'm not worried about AI job loss

#12
(In the semiconductor industry) We experienced brutal layoffs arguably due to over-investment into Ai products that produce no revenue. So we've had brutal job loss due to Ai, just not in the way people expected.

Having said that, it's hard to imagine jobs like mine (working on np-complete problems) existing if the LLMs continue advancing at the current rate, and its hard to imagine they wont continue to accelerate since they're writing themselves now, so the limitations of human ability are no longer a bottleneck.

Re: I'm not worried about AI job loss

#13
post #9

Labor substitution is extremely difficult and almost everybody hand waves it away. Take even the most unskilled labor that people can think about such as flipping a burger at a restaurant like McDonald's. In reality that job is multiple different roles mixed into one that are constantly changing. Multiple companies have experimented with machines and robots to perform this task all with very limited success and none…

>the most unskilled labor

People are worried about white-collar not blue-collar jobs being replaced. Robotics is obviously a whole different field from AI.

Re: I'm not worried about AI job loss

#14
post #4

I read that essay on Twitter the other day and thought that it was a mildly interesting expression of one end of the "AI is coming for our jobs" thing but a little slop-adjacent and not worth sharing further. And it's now at 80 million views! https://x.com/mattshumer_/status/2021256989876109403 It appears to have really caught the zeitgeist.

Well the zeitgeist is that our brains are so fried that such piece of mediocre writing penned by a GPT-container startupper can surge to the top

Re: I'm not worried about AI job loss

#15
post #4

I read that essay on Twitter the other day and thought that it was a mildly interesting expression of one end of the "AI is coming for our jobs" thing but a little slop-adjacent and not worth sharing further. And it's now at 80 million views! https://x.com/mattshumer_/status/2021256989876109403 It appears to have really caught the zeitgeist.

Let me get something straight: That essay was completely fake, right? He/It was lying about everything, and it was some sort of... what?

Did the 80 million people believe what they were reading?

Have we now transitioned to a point where we gaslight everyone for the hell of it just because we can, and call it, what, thought-provoking?

Re: I'm not worried about AI job loss

#16
post #11
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"For quality of life, it is better to err on the side of being an optimist and wrong, rather than a pessimist and right." -Elon Musk

Optimism is a luxury for those who won't be the ones paying for the mistake.

I'm optimistic that my favorite team will play well this season.

I ain't paying for shit.

Re: I'm not worried about AI job loss

#17
post #7
post #2

Maybe you should be a little worried. A healthy fear never killed anyone.

"For quality of life, it is better to err on the side of being an optimist and wrong, rather than a pessimist and right." -Elon Musk

Profound quotes are only profound when said by someone who's widely respected.

Re: I'm not worried about AI job loss

#18
No it's not a February 2020 moment for sure. In February 2020, most people had heard of COVID and a few scattered outbreaks happened, but people generally viewed the topic as more of a curiosity (like major world news but not necessarily something that will deeply impact them). This is more like start of March 2020 for general awareness.

Re: I'm not worried about AI job loss

#19
post #7
post #2

Maybe you should be a little worried. A healthy fear never killed anyone.

"For quality of life, it is better to err on the side of being an optimist and wrong, rather than a pessimist and right." -Elon Musk

Is that true? I’m not so sure. In the 1950s I could have been optimistic that asbestos won’t give people cancer.

“Some of you may die, but that’s a risk I’m willing to make” -also Elon Mush probably

Re: I'm not worried about AI job loss

#20
You are not worrried for one of the 2 reasons:

1 You are not affected somehow (you got savings, connections, not living paycheck to paycheck, and have food on the table).

2 You prefer to persue no troubles in matters of complexity.

Time will tell, is showing it already.

Post reply on HN