Live data from Hacker News

Startup pack gives away $10k worth of tools to new businesses

startuppack.org

31–40 of 53 posts

Re: Startup pack gives away $10k worth of tools to new businesses

#31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That seems fairly disturbing; couldn't you just say "you must follow @startuppack to be eligible"? Then you wouldn't need ongoing write permission to the user's Twitter account.

Disturbing is an exaggeration, but it would certainly be just as easy to get read only rights (just to confirm it's you) and also check to see if they're following.

Dude, don't lower the standards.

Re: Startup pack gives away $10k worth of tools to new businesses

#32

I'm genuinely curious... why do so many people seem to think this is a phishing scam? If your business is registered by a US state, that information is on the public record. It includes your name, business address, and date of registration. Your company URL, and company email as well aren't supposed to be private info. I'd expect you'd have them prominently placed on your website. I know I do.

There's a lot of reasons people incorporate in delaware...

http://www.quora.com/Can-members-of-a-Delaware-LLC-be-anonym...

Re: Startup pack gives away $10k worth of tools to new businesses

#33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I should add, or enjoy the service free and refer others to us, some of whom may join as paying users later.

So, can I get one even though I incorporated 2.5 years ago? It's just lead gen...

Not our program, the creator decided that. We personally wouldn't care, you could write to ask.

Re: Startup pack gives away $10k worth of tools to new businesses

#34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That seems fairly disturbing; couldn't you just say "you must follow @startuppack to be eligible"? Then you wouldn't need ongoing write permission to the user's Twitter account.

Disturbing is an exaggeration, but it would certainly be just as easy to get read only rights (just to confirm it's you) and also check to see if they're following.

I have rejected a large number of apps because they want write access to my twitter account for no discernible reason.

The reason posted above makes sense but it would never have occurred to me so I would have rejected this out of hand.

Companies should say why they need write access with clear reasoning if they want me to use them.

Re: Startup pack gives away $10k worth of tools to new businesses

#36

Will there be any exceptions for companies that are not (yet) incorporated? E.g. a company that has many big name clients/users, great product, solid community and following, etc.?

I've been thinking a lot about incorporating just to have a place for my projects. This could be yet another reason to do so.

Re: Startup pack gives away $10k worth of tools to new businesses

#37
post #12

This year of incorporation requirement seems to miss the point... I incorporated in 2010 (missed the cutoff date to qualify by 17 days) but the registration was mostly to hold the name way before I had started to develop the product. Now I'm getting to the point where I could use the help but because I registered the name too long ago I can't partake? Seems like the qualification should have more to do with how long…

Date of incorporation is an easy to measure, non-fuzzy data point. How do you determine the date of becoming active?

Well considering they're doing that verification via image/document files, why not allow applicants to also submit tax returns? Seems like that would quickly show whether or not a business has been active.

Re: Startup pack gives away $10k worth of tools to new businesses

#38
It's a shame they require us to be incorporated. We're holding off so far because it doesn't make sense until we either get investment or our first real employee. But at that time we will most likely be able to aford these tools. It doesn't make sense to me why they require the incorporation when it's the unincorporated companies that need this package the most :(

Re: Startup pack gives away $10k worth of tools to new businesses

#39

I'm genuinely curious... why do so many people seem to think this is a phishing scam? If your business is registered by a US state, that information is on the public record. It includes your name, business address, and date of registration. Your company URL, and company email as well aren't supposed to be private info. I'd expect you'd have them prominently placed on your website. I know I do.

There's a lot of reasons people incorporate in delaware... http://www.quora.com/Can-members-of-a-Delaware-LLC-be-anonym...

Err, ok. Most of the reasons hav to do with a predictable and efficient legal and tax system. I don't think many startups have a need to keep their founders names secret.

Re: Startup pack gives away $10k worth of tools to new businesses

#40
Smart. Target your audience, and reduce the CaC by defraying the high value opt in cost to partners. Signed up, as we're in the window, and it couldn't come at a better time for us. Just about to launch out of alpha so we'll be getting our money's worth.

Onboarding b2b customers isn't easy, or cheap, so this is crafty move, well played.

Post reply on HN