Live data from Hacker News

Officials Claim Drone Incursion Led to Shutdown of El Paso Airport

nytimes.com

141–150 of 631 posts

Re: Officials Claim Drone Incursion Led to Shutdown of El Paso Airport

#141

As someone else mentioned, there’s some speculation in aviation subreddits that the bounds of the altitude restriction map to the MANPAD capabilities that some cartels are purported to have. https://www.reddit.com/r/aviation/comments/1r1s4zt/comment/o... My read is that the admin is planning forceful strikes on the cartels within Mexico and is worried about their ability to retaliate by taking down US aircraft across…

Would that account for the trapezoidal shape of the one restricted area?

Re: Officials Claim Drone Incursion Led to Shutdown of El Paso Airport

#142

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well, air travel spreads things harder and faster.

Sure, but people will just drive to the next closest airport and fly. Quarantine makes no sense as an explanation without accompanying roadblocks.

>Sure, but people will just drive to the next closest airport and fly

Tell me you've never been to west Texas.

Re: Officials Claim Drone Incursion Led to Shutdown of El Paso Airport

#143

As someone else mentioned, there’s some speculation in aviation subreddits that the bounds of the altitude restriction map to the MANPAD capabilities that some cartels are purported to have. https://www.reddit.com/r/aviation/comments/1r1s4zt/comment/o... My read is that the admin is planning forceful strikes on the cartels within Mexico and is worried about their ability to retaliate by taking down US aircraft across…

It seems crazy not to just, tell people that if that's what it is. "Hey if you are flying above 18,000 please don't go lower because you could be blown up by a MANPAD."

If the cartels have MANPADS then our intel is already blown by issuing the TFR, so what's the harm in just saying it out loud?

Re: Officials Claim Drone Incursion Led to Shutdown of El Paso Airport

#144

As someone else mentioned, there’s some speculation in aviation subreddits that the bounds of the altitude restriction map to the MANPAD capabilities that some cartels are purported to have. https://www.reddit.com/r/aviation/comments/1r1s4zt/comment/o... My read is that the admin is planning forceful strikes on the cartels within Mexico and is worried about their ability to retaliate by taking down US aircraft across…

Would that account for the trapezoidal shape of the one restricted area?

My bet is a showy armored advance though the open terrain near there… it’ll look great on camera! /s

Re: Officials Claim Drone Incursion Led to Shutdown of El Paso Airport

#145

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sure, but people will just drive to the next closest airport and fly. Quarantine makes no sense as an explanation without accompanying roadblocks.

>Sure, but people will just drive to the next closest airport and fly Tell me you've never been to west Texas.

The next closest airport is Juarez, it's like 6 miles away, full fledged international airport. It's a few hours walk at worst.

Re: Officials Claim Drone Incursion Led to Shutdown of El Paso Airport

#147

Action to close airspace over a major city in the US for security reasons over extended period hasn’t happened since 9/11. 10 day closure for security reasons seems really long. edit: Same restriction imposed around Santa Teresa, New Mexico. ~15 miles northwest of the El Paso airport.

El Paso is the 6th largest city in Texas so not “major” but certainly large.

25th largest in the United States.

Re: Officials Claim Drone Incursion Led to Shutdown of El Paso Airport

#149

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The not-totally-crazy ideas from Reddit include: - it's related to the annouced GPS disruption test (although that's a really long time and doesn't seem urgent enough) - someone in Mexico is getting kidnapped by Gov - nuclear tests I wish those were crazy ideas, but here we are...

I don't know which Reddit thread you're reading (there are many I'm sure) but the one in r/Aviation seems to have a favourite theory that there was a credible threat of someone with MANPADS, which are shoulder-launched surface-to-air missiles and not some sort of sanitary product. Apparently they have a ceiling of 18,000ft which is exactly the limit of the restriction in El Paso. Aircraft are allowed fly over if they…

That's also just the cutoff for class A airspace. I think people are reading too much into the specific height.

Re: Officials Claim Drone Incursion Led to Shutdown of El Paso Airport

#150
post #71

Am I hallucinating? Wasn't there just an identical thread on the front page not even an hour ago?

You aren’t, probably was flagged down by not being hacker enough (or more likely for being an open invitation to runaway speculation without any grounding in reality and facts)

You've just described every comment section on HackerNews.
Post reply on HN