Live data from Hacker News

Discord Alternatives, Ranked

taggart-tech.com

141–150 of 489 posts

Re: Discord Alternatives, Ranked

#141
post #109

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How could Signal be considered privacy-conscious ? The first thing they do is ask for your phone number.

Signal has profiles nowadays that can be used to connect with people without sharing phone numbers. The latter are only used for signup and discarded immediately after.

I don't know how Signal works and I never used it, but could I signup with a phone number and keep using it with another number, on the same phone?

Re: Discord Alternatives, Ranked

#142
post #84

This does miss a major feature of Discord and why, imo, it got such an huge following among gamers at first: voice and video chat. I've really had a hard time finding a Discord alternative that has the same kind of first-class voice and video chat support that Discord does. Back to Ventrilo and Mumble I guess /s

Why can't anybody just add a button to host a fully P2P WebRTC call? Like everyone did back when Slack didn't have anything, but in one click?

I did this as a side project awhile ago it was very fun.

https://github.com/adhamsalama/webrtc

I didn't bother adding much styling to the website because I was only interested in the network side of things.

Re: Discord Alternatives, Ranked

#144

We are also currently working on a privacy-focused alternative called Kloak, which is in its very early alpha stage. We would greatly appreciate your feedback on areas for improvement and any expectations you may have for the platform. Here is a quick promo video as well - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ekOxAg7leXM

It is closed source, right?

Re: Discord Alternatives, Ranked

#146
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is there a recommended or "blessed" server and client combo for someone who just wants to migrate their friends off discord? The main site https://xmpp.org/software/ lists lots of different options but I have no idea what core/advanced means and comparing all of these would take ages.

The ironic part is that those software description files are meaningless. AstraChat claims Advanced in all categories, but it's a proprietary commercial software, so nobody ran any kind of test suite to verify this. That software list, how it's done and how it's ranked is literally confirming my initial point of critique :D Last time I tried out several chat clients, most of them were alpha software, had lots of bugs…

> I just wish there was some kind of ACID test suite for XMPP or something else to reproducibly validate spec compliance. Maybe a test server or similar as a reference implementation. This way client or server maintainers would have to run their programs against the official test server to increase their compliance stats.

This is exactly what the Compliance Suits are for, and the XMPP Software Fundation is taking care of telling all the clients what they misses directly on the official website, for example: https://xmpp.org/software/movim/

Re: Discord Alternatives, Ranked

#147
post #126

I don't understand the appeal of any of those, least of all Discord itself. It's unsearcheable, focused on immediacy, confusing and full of blinking things. The old Reddit interface (or current HN one!) are unsurpassed IMHO.

Most people are on Discord, joining servers has very little friction (no separate accounts), there's decent bots and mod tools and such, ability to create as many channels per server as you want (e.g. for discussions, media, music, whatever) and participate in text based conversations more or less live. It's also easy to jump into a VC and chat while you play games with friends, share screen, stuff like that. Most al…

It does have a weird source of friction. The need to find an invite to the "server". Sometimes you'll find one but it will be dead. There's no way to search to find a server then join it as far as I know.

Re: Discord Alternatives, Ranked

#149

We are also currently working on a privacy-focused alternative called Kloak, which is in its very early alpha stage. We would greatly appreciate your feedback on areas for improvement and any expectations you may have for the platform. Here is a quick promo video as well - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ekOxAg7leXM

It is closed source, right?

For now, yes

Re: Discord Alternatives, Ranked

#150

Ironically, Signal actually ranks a -1 for privacy in this use. Presumably you're already using Signal and getting mainstream contacts to start using it too. You probably have a basic profile that at least includes your real name, and might also have your picture. Maybe you're even one of the 7 people in the world that use the Stories feature in it. Well good news, now all of that is also unconditionally available to…

I didn't think I'd ever be part of any group of 7 people in the world, but today is that day, I guess.

And I know one more of those people already!

5 more to go.

Post reply on HN