Live data from Hacker News

Why I Joined OpenAI

brendangregg.com

91–100 of 236 posts

Re: Why I Joined OpenAI

#91
post #89
post #4

> ...it's not just about saving costs – it's about saving the planet There's something that doesn't sit right with me about this statement, and I'm not sure what it is. Are you sure you didn't just join for the money? (edit: cool problems, too)

Probably because "making the world a better place" has been a trope used so much in the industry that it's made it to a TV show [1]. It's fine to be passionate about your job. It's fine to be paid well. You don't need to make us believe that you're mother Theresa on top of it. [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B8C5sjjhsso

What a gem of a TV show.

Re: Why I Joined OpenAI

#92
Did the article intentionally start with a LLM cliche to filter out all the people who hate reading obviously generated content? I would say it worked.

Re: Why I Joined OpenAI

#93
post #87

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The issue is that you're doing lot, but not saving the planet. What do you think is happening with the efficiency gains? You're making rich people richer and helping AI to become an integral (i.e. positive ROI from business perspective) part of our lives. And that's perfectly fine if it aligns with your philosophy. It's not for quite a few others, and you not owning up to it leads to all kinds of negativity in the co…

>What do you think is happening with the efficiency gains? may it happen that the efficiency gains decrease demand and thus postpone investment into and development of new and better energy sources? If one couldn't get by just by bringing 20 trucks with gas turbines, may be he would have invested in fusion development :)

> may it happen that the efficiency gains decrease demand

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox

Re: Why I Joined OpenAI

#94

To answer a few people at once: I did mention compensation as a factor in the post, but I didn't elaborate details, so easy to miss. Comp is important of course, but so are the other factors. It feels like I can't go for a day without reading about the cost of AI datacenters in the news, and I can do something about it.

Interesting. Out of curiosity, how long do you think OpenAI can survive as a company? Put another way, what would be your guesses for probability of failure on 1yr, 3yr, and 5yr horizons? EDIT: possibly a corollary--does Mia pay money for chatgpt or use a free plan?

As an engineer I can't comment on future company predictions. It sounds like a question for Sam Altman, as he has discussed risks in the past.

My wife was paying for ChatGPT before I joined. I didn't ask Mia. I probably have three months of hair growth before my next chance to ask.

Re: Why I Joined OpenAI

#96
post #12

> She was worried about a friend who was travelling in a far-away city, with little timezone overlap when they could chat, but she could talk to ChatGPT anytime about what the city was like and what tourist activities her friend might be doing, which helped her feel connected. She liked the memory feature too, saying it was like talking to a person who was living there. This seems rather sad. Is this really what AI i…

I use it as something to talk to about incredibly nerdy and/or obscure things no one else would be willing to talk about.

Same. I have a lot of ideas I like to explore that people find boring or tedious. I used to just read, but it's pleasant to have the option to play with those thoughts more.

Re: Why I Joined OpenAI

#97

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Again, many comments here saying I only care about the money, and while comp is an important factor I think it characterizes me as someone I'm not, and forgets what I've been doing for the past two decades. I've spent thousands of hours of my life writing textbooks for roughly minimum wage, as I want to help others like me (I came from nothing, with no access tech meetups or conferences, and books were the gateway to…

It's okay to want to make money. You don't really have to justify it this hard unless you want people to really think you don't think comp is important, which is a bit sus to be fair.

When did I say I don't think comp is important?

Re: Why I Joined OpenAI

#98

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's okay to want to make money. You don't really have to justify it this hard unless you want people to really think you don't think comp is important, which is a bit sus to be fair.

When did I say I don't think comp is important?

Sir, your top three comments in the comment section are about how not important the compensation package is for you

Re: Why I Joined OpenAI

#99

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's okay to want to make money. You don't really have to justify it this hard unless you want people to really think you don't think comp is important, which is a bit sus to be fair.

When did I say I don't think comp is important?

Thank you very much for your work. I think people envious of someone's compensation don't deserve a response

Re: Why I Joined OpenAI

#100

Brendan, I'm a big fan of your book, and work. I don't have a problem with you joining OpenAI; best of luck there! However, I'm not sure your analysis is quite correct, in this case. If OpenAI can mobilize X (giga)dollars to buy Y amounts of energy, your work there will not reduce X or Y, it will simply help them produce more "tokens" (or whatever "unit of AI") for a given amount of energy. So in a sense you're helpi…

Was going to say the same thing, but I'm pretty sure he already knows that. Smart people can convince themselves of everything.
Post reply on HN