Live data from Hacker News

Geologists may have solved mystery of Green River's 'uphill' route

phys.org

21–30 of 45 posts

Re: Geologists may have solved mystery of Green River's 'uphill' route

#21
post #5

Why does this article have a picture of the Maroon Bells? As opposed to something along Green River or, ideally, the 700m deep canyon being described?

> Credit: Pixabay/CC0 Public Domain

Using what they can from free, public domain sources.

Re: Geologists may have solved mystery of Green River's 'uphill' route

#22
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Having recently gotten into watching documentaries or youtube videos of accounts of mountaineering expeditions it's amazing how lazy content creators, film makers and journalists can be when choosing what images or videos to show. You'll get something about climbing a mountain in the Andes and keep getting shown completely misleading pictures of Himalayan mountains, etc.

I think it's largely because they are "content creators" instead of trying to tell a story or share information.

I'll notice this with TV documentaries and segments on news channels quite frequently as well. I have the "GeoGuessr gene" as well as being decently well travelled so I spot this stuff all the time. One particular pet peeve of mine is movies or shows mean to be shot in medieval Europe but the "forest" they use is actually a tree plantation of North American native trees such as Sitka Spruce.

Re: Geologists may have solved mystery of Green River's 'uphill' route

#23
post #5

Why does this article have a picture of the Maroon Bells? As opposed to something along Green River or, ideally, the 700m deep canyon being described?

Having recently gotten into watching documentaries or youtube videos of accounts of mountaineering expeditions it's amazing how lazy content creators, film makers and journalists can be when choosing what images or videos to show. You'll get something about climbing a mountain in the Andes and keep getting shown completely misleading pictures of Himalayan mountains, etc.

The content you create is only as good as the stock footage you have available to you. It's not like these people are trekking to the locations to acquire their own content. If you search in stock libraries for mountaineering in the Andes, and it only brings you footage from the Himalayas you're just going to use it.

Re: Geologists may have solved mystery of Green River's 'uphill' route

#24
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Having recently gotten into watching documentaries or youtube videos of accounts of mountaineering expeditions it's amazing how lazy content creators, film makers and journalists can be when choosing what images or videos to show. You'll get something about climbing a mountain in the Andes and keep getting shown completely misleading pictures of Himalayan mountains, etc.

Simple, lazy stuff like that always drives me up the wall. The HGTV show House Hunters used to be wildly inaccurate with their map location pins. On more than one occasion they'd say a couple is from the Bay Area but when they show the map the location pin would be in LA County. Like, come on. That's not even close.

Maybe the pin was closer and they were lying about it being in the Bay Area???

Also, no need for exact location for these pins. The new home owners probably are fine with it not being exact

Re: Geologists may have solved mystery of Green River's 'uphill' route

#25
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Having recently gotten into watching documentaries or youtube videos of accounts of mountaineering expeditions it's amazing how lazy content creators, film makers and journalists can be when choosing what images or videos to show. You'll get something about climbing a mountain in the Andes and keep getting shown completely misleading pictures of Himalayan mountains, etc.

Simple, lazy stuff like that always drives me up the wall. The HGTV show House Hunters used to be wildly inaccurate with their map location pins. On more than one occasion they'd say a couple is from the Bay Area but when they show the map the location pin would be in LA County. Like, come on. That's not even close.

There's a lot of duplicated geographic names in Northern and Southern California. If the production house isn't in the area, it's hard, close enough.

I lived in Burbank, but I was in the unincorporated area of Santa Clara County, not the incorporated city in LA County. Incidentally, I was living in the South Bay, but not the South Bay in LA County, or the South Bay in San Diego County.

Anyway, perhaps the couple is from the Bay Area, but their house is in LA County right now. :P

Re: Geologists may have solved mystery of Green River's 'uphill' route

#26
post #25
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Simple, lazy stuff like that always drives me up the wall. The HGTV show House Hunters used to be wildly inaccurate with their map location pins. On more than one occasion they'd say a couple is from the Bay Area but when they show the map the location pin would be in LA County. Like, come on. That's not even close.

There's a lot of duplicated geographic names in Northern and Southern California. If the production house isn't in the area, it's hard, close enough. I lived in Burbank, but I was in the unincorporated area of Santa Clara County, not the incorporated city in LA County. Incidentally, I was living in the South Bay, but not the South Bay in LA County, or the South Bay in San Diego County. Anyway, perhaps the couple is f…

A specific one that I'll never forget was actually a House Hunters International episode. It was years ago but the pin being off by about 400 miles burned it into my memory lol

I think they were moving from Market Street to Amsterdam.

Re: Geologists may have solved mystery of Green River's 'uphill' route

#27
post #17
post #7

For people interested in the subject generally I highly recommend John McPhee's anthology "Annals of the Former World." Actually I highly recommend everything John McPhee has written but this is a good start :).

References to his books should carry a warning - something to the effect of: "may inspire circuitous road trips involving many stops dangerously examining road-cuts on busy interstate highways"

I would pay good money for a field guide/itinerary to accompany "Assembling California".

More directly related to the Green River, I found Wayne Ranney's "Carving Grand Canyon: Evidence, Theories, and Mystery" an accessible/engaging intro to deep geological mysteries.

Re: Geologists may have solved mystery of Green River's 'uphill' route

#29
post #25
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Simple, lazy stuff like that always drives me up the wall. The HGTV show House Hunters used to be wildly inaccurate with their map location pins. On more than one occasion they'd say a couple is from the Bay Area but when they show the map the location pin would be in LA County. Like, come on. That's not even close.

There's a lot of duplicated geographic names in Northern and Southern California. If the production house isn't in the area, it's hard, close enough. I lived in Burbank, but I was in the unincorporated area of Santa Clara County, not the incorporated city in LA County. Incidentally, I was living in the South Bay, but not the South Bay in LA County, or the South Bay in San Diego County. Anyway, perhaps the couple is f…

Clearly they're referring to the Santa Monica Bay Area

Re: Geologists may have solved mystery of Green River's 'uphill' route

#30
post #7

For people interested in the subject generally I highly recommend John McPhee's anthology "Annals of the Former World." Actually I highly recommend everything John McPhee has written but this is a good start :).

Can vouch for his “Oranges” too! A phenomenal writer
Post reply on HN