Live data from Hacker News

TIL: Apple Broke Time Machine Again on Tahoe

taoofmac.com

61–70 of 157 posts

Re: TIL: Apple Broke Time Machine Again on Tahoe

#61
Apple has always had problems with SMB since they switched from one of the open-source implementations to one it internally developed, many yaers ago.

Then again, SMB especially in its newer versions seems to be a protocol developed by MS with one of its goals being to make third-party implementations as difficult as possible.

Re: TIL: Apple Broke Time Machine Again on Tahoe

#62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hasn't the issues always been related to remote Time Machine? I have a usb drive I use and haven't heard of any issues with that setup. Am I missing something?

I lose my Time Machine drive, like, every year or two. Sometimes, Time Machine just goes stupid and I have to wipe the drive and start over. All of my efforts in the past to copy or repair or do anything to a Time Machine drive has ended in folly, so when it starts acting up, I just wipe it and start anew. Other times, it's the drive itself, and I swap it out. 99% of the time, it Just Works. Wiping the drive for me i…

Apple customers pay for backup solutions to backup data they don't care about and they don't even care when it fails.

The bar is so low!

Re: TIL: Apple Broke Time Machine Again on Tahoe

#65
post #13

The author posted a fix, but how do I check if there is a problem in the first place?

Hi! OP here. In my case Time Machine stopped doing backups to the server, period, and would keep silently refusing to do so. I encourage you to check backups are happening.

Re: TIL: Apple Broke Time Machine Again on Tahoe

#66

I use the same setup and was able to restore some files I recently deleted. My SMB settings in Synology were set to what the recommended settings were already. Not sure what happened in this person's case, but it also seems like he backed up and didn't test the restores. Which isn't good practice.

Hi! OP here. No, that was not it. Time Machine just quietly failed to do any backups and I failed to notice they weren't happening.

Re: TIL: Apple Broke Time Machine Again on Tahoe

#67
Just for the record: I wanted to see your content, but I couldn't because in Spain when there's football they block most websites to "avoid illegal football IP lists"... LaLiga can block anything they want without any restriction, even you website which I doubt about it. I can barely navigate... I will read it later tomorrow. This why you might see 0 traffic from Spain.

Re: TIL: Apple Broke Time Machine Again on Tahoe

#69

restic and kopia should work decently, if with a bit of setup, I think both can just mount backup as FUSE filesystem The backup system that silently breaks when it doesn't like something in backend is not worth time

I did indeed switch to restic for everyday backup. Here I wrote about how to set it up so it has full disk access, uses TochID to access the secret and runs daily: https://github.com/patte/restic-macos-app
Post reply on HN