Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Do you also "hoard" notes/links but struggle to turn them into actions?

news.ycombinator.com

51–60 of 228 posts

Re: Ask HN: Do you also "hoard" notes/links but struggle to turn them into actions?

#51

The only thing that's ever worked is a piece of paper and a pen. Never really look back more than a week. Not sophisticated, but it moves me forward.

Realizing graveyard of good intentions is not that valuable is one of the most important things that we have to learn. Best to just cut it and work on what is ahead.

Re: Ask HN: Do you also "hoard" notes/links but struggle to turn them into actions?

#52

So here's what's worked for me over the years - I collect interesting links/pages/stuff by emailing myself notes about them. I never actually _do_ anything with these notes, but from time to time I open the "Notes To Self" folder and skim through them. Anything that seems worthless I delete, anything that seems obvious I delete, the rest just sit there. And that's more useful than you'd think - by reviewing them semi…

I do something similar but also cooy the most interesting of these into Obsidian. Doesn't take long and the activity of sorting helps me remember. It's amazing how often when I skim these that I find something interesting/profound/useful that I've forgotten.

Re: Ask HN: Do you also "hoard" notes/links but struggle to turn them into actions?

#53
For what it’s worth:

- Workflowy is great for taking notes in meetings, allowing ad-hoc moving things around. It’s also great for reference material (what was that long command SQL query I use). But yes it’s also a graveyard.

- AirTable worked somewhat to keep moving projects forward, without growing unbounded. But only when there is a workflow. That looks like: dump tasks into rows, then create the steps as views of those tasks with different filters. So tasks essentially move systematically from uncategorized, no time estimate, no schedule, to getting tagged with all of that, and then I can narrow it down to see just what’s on the agenda for today’s date. I also have it show the sum of estimated time per date, because I inevitably end up scheduling 30 hours of tasks for a day, so that helps keep me honest on what’s achievable. I did the same thing in Workflowy with custom JavaScript but AirTable seemed more effective for this. Tasks also get linked to project buckets, and I basically then just try to keep every bucket moving forward (don’t let any active bucket get starved).

- I could throw all of this into an LLM and have it tell me what I should be working on, remind me about what I’m forgetting, and so on. But I’m basically not interested, because I’d have to give it additional context that would be beyond what I’m interested or allowed to share. Like, I’ll ask a generic question for advice to an LLM but if an LLM is going to remind me to ”call Robert about Project Mayhem, then it needs to know about Robert and Project Mayhem.

Re: Ask HN: Do you also "hoard" notes/links but struggle to turn them into actions?

#54
I started using obsidian about a year ago and I have found it to be an invaluable tool.

The key is using it to solve problems you actually have, rather than problems you want to have.

I was losing track of people's contact details --> I made an addressbook in obsidian.

I wanted to track my exercise to find out how much I was running each week --> make graphs

And so on. Your obsidian should get a bit messy before you try to impose order on it. Use it to solve a problem badly (Just writing down how far I run in a daily diary note) then improve (Writing a query to turn all of those notes into a graph).

Personally I don't use any AI with my knowledge base. Good searching tools and a little bit of organization are the most useful thing for me.

Personally, I think keeping lots of notes/links is a kind of digital hoarding. Just like real hoarding, it's an emotional problem not an organizational problem. If you can work out what emotional need hoarding links is fulfilling for you then you're on the way to working out how to get that emotional need fulfilled by something else.

Re: Ask HN: Do you also "hoard" notes/links but struggle to turn them into actions?

#55
post #29

To some extent I wish there was a bookmarking / note keeping service with snapshots and context based (local LLM?) search solving this. My main problem with bookmarks / notes that I forget about them. I don't need a bookmark keeping service, I need one which would bring them forward when I look for something, based on context too. Something like which also makes a plain text searchable snapshot of the page.

+1 for this - I have a ton of links saved up and a system that stored them in a searchable list, saved a copy of each site (PDF would be good enough), and then fed it all to an LLM that could give me relevant info when I needed it, would be ideal. I'm planning to try something like linkding for the first two, if I can find the time.

Re: Ask HN: Do you also "hoard" notes/links but struggle to turn them into actions?

#56

I had been hoarding links/notes to movies/tv shows for some time, saved to a plain text file. Often by sharing links from other apps (ie. Reddit or Letterboxd), paired with hashtags, using an iOS app I built. Finally extracted the data for these hashtags and fed it to an LLM to organize. I'm happy with the result https://xenodium.com/film-tv-bookmarks-chaos-resolved

That is an interesting film/TV watch list, I might have to harvest that for my own!

Re: Ask HN: Do you also "hoard" notes/links but struggle to turn them into actions?

#59
post #21

At some point, organisation can become a form of procrastination. Building a second brain is not Doing The Thing.[0] A note is not an intention. It commits to memory, not to action. I really don't care about having a whole searchable, tagged database; I hardly ever look at those notes again. At work I have topic-based Markdown notes. Sometimes I collect information about a topic for a few weeks or months, and eventua…

Me too, I already exported my data from all platforms including HN and indexed them in a RAG database but I don't feel like using them much. They are past oriented and I need present oriented stuff. With LLMs I noticed I don't like when they use chat history search or memory functions, it makes them fall into a rut and become less creative.

I even got to a point where I made an "anti-memory system" - a MCP tool that just calls a model without context from the full conversation or past conversations, to get a fresh perspective. And I instruct the host model to reveal only partially the information we discussed, explaining that creativity is sparked when LLMs get to see not too much, not too little - like a sexy dress.

Re: Ask HN: Do you also "hoard" notes/links but struggle to turn them into actions?

#60
post #2

If you answered Q1–Q3 above, that already helps a ton. I also made a 3-min survey to aggregate patterns. I’ll share a summary of results and invite early testers if there’s real demand: https://concerns.vercel.app

Update (31st. Jan. 2026) Recurring themes/pains from replies so far (tl;dr)

1.On-demand recall & retrieval is the core pain: people capture a lot but can’t reliably resurface the right note/link at the right time; they want stronger search (fuzzy/semantic), snapshots/context, and “pull-based” recall when needed.

2.Privacy/local-first is a hard requirement for many: “no cloud, no third-party access,” ideally open-source and self-hostable; any AI must run fully on-device to be trusted.

3.Low-friction matters more than perfect organization: users prefer systems that don’t force structure or add maintenance overhead—messy-first, iterate only when a real problem appears.

4.Avoid interruption by default: many dislike proactive “AI suggestions”; they want controlled resurfacing (opt-in prompts), not constant nudges.

5.Different goals coexist: for many, notes are for memory/inspiration/reference (not turning into tasks), while others want action workflows—tools should respect both modes.

6.Cost and scalability must be predictable: long-term indexing (years of notes/history) can get expensive; pricing needs to be transparent and not “per task,” and context signals across tools are often noisy/unreliable.

Post reply on HN