Live data from Hacker News

Putting Gemini to Work in Chrome

blog.google

41–50 of 64 posts

Re: Putting Gemini to Work in Chrome

#41

Serious question, not snark: Does anyone actually want this? I honestly can't imagine a use for these features even among people tech savvy enough to understand them.

Google shareholders want it. If search collapses they need a new stupidly profitable golden goose else Google has a giant hole in their finances

Re: Putting Gemini to Work in Chrome

#42
One more reason not to use chrome. I don't want this AI bloat. And for sure I don't want to redirect my personal website content through googles privacy sucking data pipelines.

What I just discovered: The good old google search without AI bloat but with privacy via https://www.startpage.com. Highly recommended!

Re: Putting Gemini to Work in Chrome

#43

Serious question, not snark: Does anyone actually want this? I honestly can't imagine a use for these features even among people tech savvy enough to understand them.

Right now I paste screenshots of AWS/Azure/GCP into Claude and ask it questions on how to navigate around / what to do / how to set things up. This seems like a much better experience solely to not have to deal with the weird mac screenshot UX.

Re: Putting Gemini to Work in Chrome

#45
post #6

I must be using web browsers completely wrong. Like browsing a page isn't a problem for me. I can do it at the speed of my needs. I'm having a hard time understanding why I will tell gemini to create an account on some website for me or send an email. Those are usually just a tab away. That's why I feel like I'm missing something here.

I feel that way about IDEs too, though. My text editor has snippets, my file manager shows me what files are where, and my terminal lets me run programs. Why it's important to people that these functions to be grafted into a single window escapes me.

This is satire, right?

Re: Putting Gemini to Work in Chrome

#47

> We’re also bringing the creative power of Nano Banana directly into Chrome, allowing you to transform images on the fly without needing to download and re-upload images or open another tab. Are there really people who are like "Man, if only I could this straight in Chrome" ? Is this something worth bloating a browser (further) with?

Honestly? Yeah. Not really Gemini or AI chat bot stuff, but I definitely appreciate when the software I use that interacts with images includes at least some minor drawing/highlighting/text overlay capabilities. So, while I don't like this feature in particular, I'm not against the general idea.

Re: Putting Gemini to Work in Chrome

#48
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I feel that way about IDEs too, though. My text editor has snippets, my file manager shows me what files are where, and my terminal lets me run programs. Why it's important to people that these functions to be grafted into a single window escapes me.

This is satire, right?

No. Why would you think that's satire?

Re: Putting Gemini to Work in Chrome

#49
post #12
post #6

I must be using web browsers completely wrong. Like browsing a page isn't a problem for me. I can do it at the speed of my needs. I'm having a hard time understanding why I will tell gemini to create an account on some website for me or send an email. Those are usually just a tab away. That's why I feel like I'm missing something here.

Basically none of their examples are just "browse a page"? They're multi-step tasks combining data from multiple pages. Like the first example in the demo carousel (the Y2K party) starts from a photo and a prompt of roughly "buy the props needed for replicating this photo from Etsy". It first analyzes the image in the current tab, identifies a bunch of things to buy, searches for them on Etsy, customizes the orders,…

Maybe I’m a curmudgeon who can’t imagine throwing an elaborate Y2K party because all my friends were alive and threw parties at the real Y2K, but… these all feel extremely contrived.

It’s as if they used AI to generate use cases for their AI tool because they weren’t really sure what it’s for…

Re: Putting Gemini to Work in Chrome

#50

> We’re also bringing the creative power of Nano Banana directly into Chrome, allowing you to transform images on the fly without needing to download and re-upload images or open another tab. Are there really people who are like "Man, if only I could this straight in Chrome" ? Is this something worth bloating a browser (further) with?

I think Google PMs would respond by saying that nobody in 2007 was like "Man, if only I could get rid of the physical keyboard on my smartphone". You know, the whole "faster horse" argument.

Yeah but I asked for a faster horse and they keep showing up with a two-headed walrus.
Post reply on HN