Live data from Hacker News

Genetic data from over 20k U.S. children misused for 'race science'

nytimes.com

1–10 of 88 posts

Re: Genetic data from over 20k U.S. children misused for 'race science'

#5

I can't take any of this seriously so long as any research on race and intelligence continues to be banned as heresy rather than being discussed scientifically.

For one the idea of race is a social, not scientific, construct. It doesn’t mean anything scientifically.

Re: Genetic data from over 20k U.S. children misused for 'race science'

#6

I can't take any of this seriously so long as any research on race and intelligence continues to be banned as heresy rather than being discussed scientifically.

The person in question in the article is kirkegaard, you should not take seriously what he does anyway

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_Diversity_Foundation

edit since i was feeling really daring today i found an old archived page of a wiki holding a lot of interesting thoughts from him, such as eugenics to prevent the loss of western civilization, and other points that at this point you should imagine. link: https://web.archive.org/web/20250416005529/https:/rationalwi...

Re: Genetic data from over 20k U.S. children misused for 'race science'

#7

I can't take any of this seriously so long as any research on race and intelligence continues to be banned as heresy rather than being discussed scientifically.

Yeah I agree, considering how much my black kid is beating all the other white kids intellectually. Good to know you know your place. /s

Re: Genetic data from over 20k U.S. children misused for 'race science'

#8

I can't take any of this seriously so long as any research on race and intelligence continues to be banned as heresy rather than being discussed scientifically.

For one the idea of race is a social, not scientific, construct. It doesn’t mean anything scientifically.

Some medicines work better or worse depending on race. Based on the scientific methodology, your statement is incorrect.

Re: Genetic data from over 20k U.S. children misused for 'race science'

#9
It seems weird for the government to collect data useful for research, but then to gate access based on the viewpoints of potential users. This restriction doesn't support the search for truth.

Whatever people think of Lasker (Cremieux) and his views, isn't data being available to all interested parties the best way to find the truth?

The article mentions this towards the very end:

  Adam Candeub, the top lawyer at the Federal Communications Commission, wrote a law review article in 2024 criticizing the N.I.H.’s discouragement of stigmatizing research. He compared it to the persecution of Galileo.
  “A liberal society should support the search for truth,” Mr. Candeub wrote, “regardless of how uncomfortable and unsettling that truth turns out to be.”

Re: Genetic data from over 20k U.S. children misused for 'race science'

#10

I can't take any of this seriously so long as any research on race and intelligence continues to be banned as heresy rather than being discussed scientifically.

The person in question in the article is kirkegaard, you should not take seriously what he does anyway https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_Diversity_Foundation edit since i was feeling really daring today i found an old archived page of a wiki holding a lot of interesting thoughts from him, such as eugenics to prevent the loss of western civilization, and other points that at this point you should imagine. link: http…

Interesting comparing these two entries:

https://grokipedia.com/page/OpenPsych

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OpenPsych

Post reply on HN