Live data from Hacker News

Poland's energy grid was targeted by never-before-seen wiper malware

arstechnica.com

21–30 of 158 posts

Re: Poland's energy grid was targeted by never-before-seen wiper malware

#21
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Russia is at war with Europe.

have you seen the competence in those who manage the infrastructure? i'd say i would need significant proof before assuming anything. And IF russia is doing it, I would still say that we should put 99% blame on the absolute incompetents running the infrastructure, 1% russia.

If you did then you'd be extremely gullible.

Re: Poland's energy grid was targeted by never-before-seen wiper malware

#22
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What I am starting to appreciate about these digital infrastructure attacks is that they may be reversible and or temporary. It can be a nice feature.

Then you're missing the point. If they succeed they may well not be reversible. The question is if this had succeeded would we have shrugged it off again or responded appropriately?

I wasn't commenting on any particular case. I was stating that flipping a switch is less costly to reverse than blowing up a dam.

Re: Poland's energy grid was targeted by never-before-seen wiper malware

#23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Then you're missing the point. If they succeed they may well not be reversible. The question is if this had succeeded would we have shrugged it off again or responded appropriately?

I wasn't commenting on any particular case. I was stating that flipping a switch is less costly to reverse than blowing up a dam.

These attacks are not at the level of 'flipping a switch'. If they succeed they can destabilize the grid and that has the potential to destroy gear, and while not as costly as blowing up a dam it can still be quite costly.

Re: Poland's energy grid was targeted by never-before-seen wiper malware

#24
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Russia is at war with Europe.

have you seen the competence in those who manage the infrastructure? i'd say i would need significant proof before assuming anything. And IF russia is doing it, I would still say that we should put 99% blame on the absolute incompetents running the infrastructure, 1% russia.

That seems like just victim blaming - "she was asking for it with the clothes she was wearing".

Re: Poland's energy grid was targeted by never-before-seen wiper malware

#25
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

before anyone jumps on the pedantry bandwagon, its worth noting that even though open war hasn’t been called: the attacks on infrastructure especially cyber warfare is extremely active and, crucially, direct. It is totally fair to say that in a digital context, Russia is absolutely at war with Europe. As far as I can tell, they don’t even try to hide it.

Not to mention the information war they have been waging globally since 2016

True, but they’ve certainly been doing it much longer than ten years. I’ll never forget this headline [0] that struck me as purely devilish, especially in the lead up to the 2016 presidential election. Combine that with the knowledge that Trump has been anti-NATO since the 1980s [1]. Who knows how long Russia has been nudging him along. Who knows how many avenues they traverse? Take for example the letter to Senator Tom Cotton about Greenland [2]. What an embarrassment. I can only hope we are equally successful in our own PsyOps.

[0] https://www.rt.com/news/265399-putin-nato-europe-ukraine-ita...

[1] https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/ilanbenmeir/that-time-t...

[2] https://monitoring.bbc.co.uk/product/c2018djo

Re: Poland's energy grid was targeted by never-before-seen wiper malware

#26
post #7
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Russia is at war with Europe.

before anyone jumps on the pedantry bandwagon, its worth noting that even though open war hasn’t been called: the attacks on infrastructure especially cyber warfare is extremely active and, crucially, direct. It is totally fair to say that in a digital context, Russia is absolutely at war with Europe. As far as I can tell, they don’t even try to hide it.

Some could say that in the cyber realm, they are not petty, ya! Well, or something like that.

Eversince notpetya and the colonial pipeline hack, the cyber strategy game changed a lot. Notpetya was genius as a deployment, because they abused the country's tax software deployment pipeline to cripple all (and I mean all, beyond 99%) businesses in one surgical strike.

The same is gonna happen to other tax software providers, because the DATEV AG and similar companies are pretty much the definition of digital incompetence wherever you look.

I could name other takedowns but the list would continue beyond a reasonable comment, especially with vendors like Hercules and Prophete that are now insolvent because they never prioritized cyber security at all, got hacked, didn't have backups, and ran out of money due to production plant costs.

Re: Poland's energy grid was targeted by never-before-seen wiper malware

#27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I wasn't commenting on any particular case. I was stating that flipping a switch is less costly to reverse than blowing up a dam.

These attacks are not at the level of 'flipping a switch'. If they succeed they can destabilize the grid and that has the potential to destroy gear, and while not as costly as blowing up a dam it can still be quite costly.

During WW2 both germany and the UK as example were carpet bombed to assail industry, does that help you to understand my position better?

Vietnam too.

Re: Poland's energy grid was targeted by never-before-seen wiper malware

#28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

These attacks are not at the level of 'flipping a switch'. If they succeed they can destabilize the grid and that has the potential to destroy gear, and while not as costly as blowing up a dam it can still be quite costly.

During WW2 both germany and the UK as example were carpet bombed to assail industry, does that help you to understand my position better? Vietnam too.

Not really.

If you succeed in attacking the grid, you achieve the same widespread industry impact, without the cost of the munitions.

It can take decades to recover from a cyber attack like this, if it succeeds.

Re: Poland's energy grid was targeted by never-before-seen wiper malware

#29
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Does Europe overall feel and act like that’s the case though? It seems as if the European war has been pushed to the background recently, and most people kind of forgot about it. If you walk down the streets of Paris or Berlin does it look like it’s wartime, do people talk about it much, do they share the latest front news and so on?

>If you walk down the streets of Paris or Berlin does it look like it’s wartime, Like what exactly would you want them to do? Run around screaming all day because there's a war in another country 2000 km away from them? No, people just go on with their lives, doing their jobs, taking care of family and friends, paying their taxes, so that specialized workers in the ministry of defence can take care of the war stuff f…

Kyiv.

And "enjoying their daily lives" diminishes real tragedies of Ukrainians' daily lives.

Re: Poland's energy grid was targeted by never-before-seen wiper malware

#30
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

During WW2 both germany and the UK as example were carpet bombed to assail industry, does that help you to understand my position better? Vietnam too.

Not really. If you succeed in attacking the grid, you achieve the same widespread industry impact, without the cost of the munitions. It can take decades to recover from a cyber attack like this, if it succeeds.

Again, not endoring any specific case just endorsing SPECIFICITY, COST, and "Collaterals".
Post reply on HN