Live data from Hacker News

Raspberry Pi Drag Race: Pi 1 to Pi 5 – Performance Comparison

the-diy-life.com

31–40 of 94 posts

Re: Raspberry Pi Drag Race: Pi 1 to Pi 5 – Performance Comparison

#31

I finally found a job for my Raspberry Pi 1 Model B from 2012. It’s been sitting in a drawer for years, but about a 2 years ago added it to my Tailscale network as an exit node. It’s a single-core 700MHz ARMv6 chip with 512MB of RAM. It's a fossil—a Pi 5 is 600x faster (according to the video). But for the 'low-bandwidth' task of routing some banking traffic or running a few changedetection watches via a Hetzner VPS…

Well on the other hand, at which point does it become wasteful to run something when it gets less and less power efficient compared to newer devices? According to OP's benchmarks, the Pi 1 burns 2W constant to do essentially zero work and running that on a more modern device that's already running would use almost no extra power. Then again we use a kW or two to microwave things for minutes on a daily basis so who re…

[deleted]

Re: Raspberry Pi Drag Race: Pi 1 to Pi 5 – Performance Comparison

#33

I finally found a job for my Raspberry Pi 1 Model B from 2012. It’s been sitting in a drawer for years, but about a 2 years ago added it to my Tailscale network as an exit node. It’s a single-core 700MHz ARMv6 chip with 512MB of RAM. It's a fossil—a Pi 5 is 600x faster (according to the video). But for the 'low-bandwidth' task of routing some banking traffic or running a few changedetection watches via a Hetzner VPS…

Well on the other hand, at which point does it become wasteful to run something when it gets less and less power efficient compared to newer devices? According to OP's benchmarks, the Pi 1 burns 2W constant to do essentially zero work and running that on a more modern device that's already running would use almost no extra power. Then again we use a kW or two to microwave things for minutes on a daily basis so who re…

I did unplug my GPU to save 30 watts, but... 2 watts is equivalent to driving a Prius Prime 0.155 miles per day on battery power. So there's that

Re: Raspberry Pi Drag Race: Pi 1 to Pi 5 – Performance Comparison

#34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They'll run CUPS too! My B modernized some old, commercial Brother laser printers I was running.

That's a great idea - if I understood you right, you mean you used it to make a printer "wireless / wifi enabled" with it, right? Is there any guide you can recommend for that?

I've done the same thing - making a USB-only printer available on my LAN - following this guide: https://pimylifeup.com/raspberry-pi-print-server/

One nice thing is I can print to the CUPS server even if the printer is off

Re: Raspberry Pi Drag Race: Pi 1 to Pi 5 – Performance Comparison

#35

Do we think this page loads enough ads? The graphs are interesting but, really, if you’re considering your readers rather than SEOing for last decade’s search engine technology, you should lead with them and discuss the findings afterwards. I.e., get to the point quickly and then unpack the detail. It’s interesting seeing where the incremental vs revolutionary improvements have occurred. CPU-wise, a huge leap with th…

I'll always agree that sites should be clear of ads, but ad blockers are the true solution. I can't stand browsing the internet without one.

Re: Raspberry Pi Drag Race: Pi 1 to Pi 5 – Performance Comparison

#36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They'll run CUPS too! My B modernized some old, commercial Brother laser printers I was running.

That's a great idea - if I understood you right, you mean you used it to make a printer "wireless / wifi enabled" with it, right? Is there any guide you can recommend for that?

I did the same with an rpi3, not sure if I used this guide but it seems good:

https://www.raspberrypi.com/news/printing-at-home-from-your-...

Re: Raspberry Pi Drag Race: Pi 1 to Pi 5 – Performance Comparison

#37

For $50 you can pick up a used mini PC with say, i5-6500T and 8GB ram, that'll be much faster than the Pi 5. And it'll be compatible with all Linux distros. Really the Pi 3 is good enough as an edge device where you want to hook up things to the GPIO pins.

But a PC like what you’re suggesting would result in a much higher energy bill compared to a Pi if you leave it on 24/7 to use as a server.

Re: Raspberry Pi Drag Race: Pi 1 to Pi 5 – Performance Comparison

#38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well on the other hand, at which point does it become wasteful to run something when it gets less and less power efficient compared to newer devices? According to OP's benchmarks, the Pi 1 burns 2W constant to do essentially zero work and running that on a more modern device that's already running would use almost no extra power. Then again we use a kW or two to microwave things for minutes on a daily basis so who re…

I did unplug my GPU to save 30 watts, but... 2 watts is equivalent to driving a Prius Prime 0.155 miles per day on battery power. So there's that

That seems an impossible range.

This site[0] claims a Prius Prime XSE gets 1.42 miles/kWh. Or (1.42 miles /1000Wh)*2 = 0.0028 miles. Which is ~14 feet, which is significantly more in line with my expectations (though still high)

[0] https://www.motortrend.com/reviews/2024-toyota-prius-prime-x...

Re: Raspberry Pi Drag Race: Pi 1 to Pi 5 – Performance Comparison

#39
post #37

For $50 you can pick up a used mini PC with say, i5-6500T and 8GB ram, that'll be much faster than the Pi 5. And it'll be compatible with all Linux distros. Really the Pi 3 is good enough as an edge device where you want to hook up things to the GPIO pins.

But a PC like what you’re suggesting would result in a much higher energy bill compared to a Pi if you leave it on 24/7 to use as a server.

Those Intel N100 machines sip power. Supposedly with some tweaking, people have gotten them down to idle at ~2watts.

Re: Raspberry Pi Drag Race: Pi 1 to Pi 5 – Performance Comparison

#40
> The Pi 2 managed to open the browser and actually started playing back a 1080P video, which was surprising, but playback was terrible.

A Youtube tab, web browser modern enough for YouTube, and OS modern enough for that web browser, all fit in 1GB of memory? Wow.

Post reply on HN