Live data from Hacker News

Minnesota activist releases arrest video after manipulated White House version

apnews.com

41–50 of 79 posts

Re: Minnesota activist releases arrest video after manipulated White House version

#41
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

Your phrasing of the reality of democracy and voting is basically a less-polite version of where political science has been on the topic for 80ish years. The first half or so of that they spent trying to figure out some way that the stupidity and ignorance naturally balances out into… something that’s not scary. Law of averages, wisdom-of-the-crowd sorts of stuff. They eventually (more or less) gave up, finding all t…

It’s, in fact, very scary and it’s astounding it works at all.

It no longer does. Social media was the tipping point.

Religion wasn't enough to break democracy, newspapers weren't enough, radio wasn't enough, TV was almost enough... but now, with social media as the proverbial last straw, the bug is fully exploited, completely unfixable, and likely fatal.

Re: Minnesota activist releases arrest video after manipulated White House version

#43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Thank you, this is fantastic to know! I think we have to normalize requiring this or similar standards for news, it will go a long way. Ideally we would have a similar attestation from most people's cameras (on their smartphones) but that's a much harder problem to also support with 3p camera apps.

More like I won't trust anything that doesn't come from a press photographer.

And what will make them more trustworthy?

Re: Minnesota activist releases arrest video after manipulated White House version

#44
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Thank you, this is fantastic to know! I think we have to normalize requiring this or similar standards for news, it will go a long way. Ideally we would have a similar attestation from most people's cameras (on their smartphones) but that's a much harder problem to also support with 3p camera apps.

it doesnt really matter if you can just take a photo of an AI image that's been printed out

That will look like a photo of a printout though. Seems easier to just hack the hardware to get it to sign arbitrary images instead.

Re: Minnesota activist releases arrest video after manipulated White House version

#45

I remember reading an article about how terrible AI could be in the hands of a regime like China's. What a time to be alive, I guess.

all this time we were “fighting China” and now we got China… except nothing gets done :)

Evil transcends all borders, mate, and it all looks/sounds the same ultimately.

Re: Minnesota activist releases arrest video after manipulated White House version

#48
post #47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't think they'd ever answer. They'd probably block you on X if you asked. Why do you think that is?

[flagged]

It's blatant lying and misrepresentation by officials in a public office.

Sackable offence in many countries.

Principally those countries with a regard for law, order, fairness, transparency, justice, etc.

The question really is, why would this be acceptable in the USofA by any administration.

Re: Minnesota activist releases arrest video after manipulated White House version

#49
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Your phrasing of the reality of democracy and voting is basically a less-polite version of where political science has been on the topic for 80ish years. The first half or so of that they spent trying to figure out some way that the stupidity and ignorance naturally balances out into… something that’s not scary. Law of averages, wisdom-of-the-crowd sorts of stuff. They eventually (more or less) gave up, finding all t…

It’s, in fact, very scary and it’s astounding it works at all. It no longer does. Social media was the tipping point. Religion wasn't enough to break democracy, newspapers weren't enough, radio wasn't enough, TV was almost enough... but now, with social media as the proverbial last straw, the bug is fully exploited, completely unfixable, and likely fatal.

Oh, I agree. I think it more likely than not that we have invented a combo of technologies that produce an environment in which liberal democracy cannot exist outside maybe smallish countries with tight controls on incoming media from outside (so, also fairly tight foreign capital ownership rules).

The medium is the message, and I think the “message” of the global Web + social media + (now) generative AI may not include liberal democracy.

Post reply on HN