Live data from Hacker News

EU–INC – A new pan-European legal entity

eu-inc.org

311–320 of 761 posts

Re: EU–INC – A new pan-European legal entity

#312

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Because unlike the US, we don't speak the same language. The majority of Europeans, and especially those of recent generations speak incredibly good English. Most Europeans speak 2–3 languages anyway, so there is always a common language to be found. No need for one to be forced on you.

Yes, they might, but in practice and with the exception of multinational corporations and some start-ups, everyone speaks their own language. And it's all fun and games that you can speak english in restaurants, cafes, train stations and the like, and then when you want to find a job in an EU country you get hit with "do you speak our language? no? ah, we're sorry then." There's a big difference between being a touri…

Well, if you insist on not learning a non-English European language, last time I checked Ireland was still in the EU and they speak English.

But honestly, I'm not sure what the problem is. As previously mentioned by other people on this discussion, vast swathes of Eastern Europeans live and work in the West and have had no trouble whatsoever picking up the local language. As they say, the best way to learn a language is by immersion.

Most Europeans will have gone to a school where they typically learnt a minimum of one extra language and often two extra languages.

With the exception of Finnish, the majority of Western European languages are not that difficult. Its not like Chinese or Japanese which are simply impenetrable unless you went to school there or you are super-smart and managed to pick it up in later life through sheer brain power.

Re: EU–INC – A new pan-European legal entity

#313
post #250

This + abolish VAT. The amount of money stolen in VAT scams is jn bilions of euros.

This + only pay taxes where the company is founded, not where you live at that moment in time.

That's what the personal income tax is for.. and all the other taxes payed by the individual.

That way countries can compete in being the best environment for companies.

Re: EU–INC – A new pan-European legal entity

#314
post #255

Yes please! I tripped over this recently. It's a bigger deal than it might seem. You'd be surprised at some of the weird things that can happen in the current systems in the EU if you try to do business across borders. Like: your company suddenly automatically becoming deregistered, or you might get a sudden huge tax bill, or you might even inadvertently get charged with fraud. Hasn't happened so far knock on wood ,…

This doesnt fix the issue with taxation right? You would stull have to figure out where to pay taxes if you have customers from different countries.

What issue? VAT is paid by the user (collected and remitted by you) and differs by country (used to be hassle, easy today), but the taxes you pay in your country for your company is the same regardless of where the users who paid you are based (assuming there isn't something country-specific about that), it's more about where your company is tax-resident.

Unless there are permanent-establishment issues, withholding taxes, or other country-specific digital tax regimes, where your users are based shouldn't affect how/what taxes you pay.

Otherwise, if you don't have any employees or presence in other EU countries and only doing digital services B2C, you shouldn't have to do anything specific about the taxes you pay.

Re: EU–INC – A new pan-European legal entity

#315

As a Dutch person I never understood this push until someone told me (and this is true in 2026!!!) that if you open a LLC (Gmbh?) in Germany you have to physically go to the notary and have a person READ OUT all the statutes to you. The whole process including banks accounts etc... can apparently take months in total. Personally I would not create "EU-INC" but just make all local entities legal in every country. Then…

Looks like as per 2022 it is possible to register a GMBH in Germany fully online https://www.brak.de/newsroom/news/gmbh-und-ug-koennen-ab-1-a... also https://www.ihk.de/stuttgart/fuer-unternehmen/recht-und-steu... here are the online notaries: https://online.notar.de/

Firma.de estimates 6 weeks https://www.firma.de/en/company-formation/how-to-set-up-a-gm...

beglaubigt.de estimates 3 weeks https://beglaubigt.de/ug-gruenden

Holvi estimates 4 weeks https://blog.holvi.com/de/gmbh-oder-ug-gr%C3%BCnden-2025-abl...

Re: EU–INC – A new pan-European legal entity

#316

Unfortunately this does not override employment and tax laws - so you still cannot hire someone as an FTE in Paris, from a startup in Berlin for example (without them being a freelancer, or you opening a payroll / tax office in France). But hopefully we can move towards that - standardised taxation (especially VAT and corporation tax would help massively here), the abolition of notaries, standardised requirements for…

[flagged]

Ah yes the perfect scapegoat to blame for your miserable life

Re: EU–INC – A new pan-European legal entity

#317
post #216

My Dear German friends, please accept that EU-inc is a massive boost for EU competitiveness. Continuing to block progress here only proves that the EU is good at making promises on paper but fails to deliver real change. The reason this "28th regime" actually works—and bypasses the previous vetos — is that it’s optional. It doesn’t try to force Germany to change its local GmbH laws or kill the notary system overnight…

National sovereignty is not national pride. Paying company taxes to the 28th regime evicts tax contributions to the company's home nation. Massive German tax money is already today used for non-national interests. EU-inc makes this only worse.

This is incorrect. Taxes, pensions and labour laws apply according to the country where the EU Inc is operating.

Re: EU–INC – A new pan-European legal entity

#318

@dang This post is an Ad for unofficial merch, profiting from an ongoing news story. Should we change the URL ? https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/da/speech... https://tech.eu/2026/01/20/the-european-commission-launches-...

This submission originally did link to https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/da/speech..., but was later changed to this. Or two submissions (one for each URL) was linked/merged. But something used to link to the press release rather than this website, FWIW.

Also, about reducing it down to "an Ad for unofficial merch", isn't this literally the grassroot movement that led to what was announced today? Or am I getting the relationship wrong? The domain in question was registered 2024-10-09.

Re: EU–INC – A new pan-European legal entity

#319

It's inordinately difficult and expensive to start an LLC or SA in some EU countries. It's even difficult and expensive to _stop_ an LLC and dissolve it. Huge amount of risk and cost on founders and a huge distraction from running a business. I think that EU-Inc _could_ be an improvement, but it needs to avoid the committee laundry list of ideas/requirements/form fields that plagues the EU startup ecosystem. My worry…

> Huge amount of risk and cost on founders Better than potentially putting risk and costs on other companies, the country and/or it's citizens. > nonsense to protect against the perceived risk It's not a perceived risk. No rule is made without cases.

> No rule is made without cases

I can generally reverse engineer from the UK Companies Act what the cases were, but many EU countries have much more onerous requirements for what seems like no good reason? Perhaps the cases were too long in the past and things work differently now? What risks are we talking about, anyway?

Post reply on HN