Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: I quit coding years ago. AI brought me back

calquio.com

431–440 of 460 posts

Re: Show HN: I quit coding years ago. AI brought me back

#431
The graph on the BMI calculator is incorrect. While it is a pretty minor bug how many other "minor" bugs are in these tools.

It's great to produce something for free but if it wouldn't have been more then a couple of hours work to verify each of these tools, write tests etc. Even better would have been to produce a open source library

Re: Show HN: I quit coding years ago. AI brought me back

#432
post #405

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

Ah, this is the problem - the HN community is sensitive about picking up indications that an LLM has either generated or processed the language in a post. As ericbarrett said, it's far better to write in your own voice. Mistakes in English matter far less than that! Past explanations: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...

Understood! I will not use any ai tools here, even only for translations.

I realized It’s a good way to keep real persons and human generated ideas in this community by limiting ai usage.

Re: Show HN: I quit coding years ago. AI brought me back

#433

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Using an ad blocker just shifts the cost of creating/providing content onto people not using ad blockers. The enshitification of the internet is largely driven by people ad blocking, as is incentivizes more click bait, more ads, and sloppier cheap content. For engineering/software related content, the impact is immense since the audience is largely people ad blocking. I won't name names, because they fear backlash fr…

> The enshitification of the internet is largely driven by people ad blocking This is unfairly putting the blame on only one rational actor in a prisoner's dilemma. Content providers are free to put their content behind a paywall with no ads, but they choose not to. They choose not to because people don't pay for content when they can get it from other providers who don't use a paywall. Consumers then are left withou…

Just a note that many creators integrate the advertisement of their sponsors into their content presentation and not all of that can be stopped by ad blockers (most, in fact, can't). Those creators also tend to have a Patreon or similar so their content can be supported directly. And I'd wager that's a much better model for the creators than relying on ads they don't even select themselves and that possibly clash with their content. This also makes it much more clear to users that the creators directly benefit from those integrated ads, so those kinds of ads are probably much better tolerated.

Re: Show HN: I quit coding years ago. AI brought me back

#434
post #353

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> If this is true, you weren’t a very good programmer. There’s much more to code quality than refactoring working code. Yup, my conclusion exactly. With that said, most code I have seen in private sector is almost objectively horrible (and certainly subjectively). Code manufactured with the current best tools such as Claude compares favourably. Companies rarely have the patience to pay for well manicured, elegant cod…

The thing is good code doesn’t cost more than bad code in the long run. In many cases it doesn’t even cost more in the short run. And it usually has nothing to do with being manicured or elegant. A good engineer will tell you how to spend 25% of effort to get to 90% of the result you want. With maintainable code, and importantly with less code that touches fewer systems. A bad engineer will deliver exactly what produ…

I agree, for the most part.

Despite having worked with or managed hundreds of developers over the years, I don't think there were more than, maybe, 5 that I would not gladly swap for a claude-equivalent. Diligent, able to produce good code when adequately supervised, and devoid of a desire for work life balance :-)

Most software devs are just mediocre, they learn to code late in life, they work 9-5, and often stop learning as quickly as they can.

Re: Show HN: I quit coding years ago. AI brought me back

#435
post #35
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Please don't be hostile to newcomers. That's a way to destroy this place. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

How do we know if newcomers are real? I thing bigDinosaur is reacting to the fact that OP’s entire post and replies appear LLM generated.

We can't always know for sure and people frequently guess wrong. Because of that, it's important not to lead by attacking the other person, especially when they account is new, because newcomers usually don't know anything about the conventions of this site. Under these circumstances, it's mean and destructive to blast them with rudeness. Rather, we should be welcoming them and gently educating them. If they're a good new user, they'll respond well to that (you can see an example of this here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46682308). If they aren't a good new user, that will eventually become clear and the immune system (flagging, moderation, community members emailing hn@ycombinator.com, etc.) will eventually take care of it.

Re: Show HN: I quit coding years ago. AI brought me back

#436
post #374
post #345

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is it a shallow dismissal if the work doesn’t work?

Whether the dismissal is shallow is in the eye of the moderator. I have seen that before, so I am not going to touch that.

I will say it for you though. If the calculator doesn't work or shows wrong results, then it is shit. I don't care if made with AI, humans or monkeys.

`Professional Calculators

Free, accurate, and easy-to-use tools for finance, math, and everyday calculations.`

So yeah, fuck this. Website looks 99% similar to the many shadcn themes available, has some errors in the calculations and then have a new account propagating 'ohhh look at me, I did all this with Claude/GPT/my aunt's raspberry pi running X, AI is amazing. All Hail AI.` is tiring and I'm just going to assume it is either paid marketing, people invested directly or indirectly in these companies or just sycophant idiots.

Also, anyone knows an extension or website where I can just filter submissions if they include AI or LLM or Clause in the title? Getting really tired of this shit.

Re: Show HN: I quit coding years ago. AI brought me back

#437
post #82

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is such a... unique angle. Of all the things to get angry at AI for, web crawlers and the impact on cloudflare outages are the ones that really grinds your gears?

Not unique at all. eg a few days ago https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46608840

The difference is context: that link is a service saying they're having to make some changes, because of AI crawlers.

The context here is it's a HN post about someone being excited about AI bringing them back to coding, in response to a comment on that HN post with someone else being excited about the useful things they've been able to do about AI.

In that context, it's a unique choice to respond with a load of confrontational and rhetorical questions about AI being bad because crawlers and cloudflare outages. It reads like the they just wanted 2 excited programmers to feel bad about themselves for using AI. It's not really the sort of response I'd expect here.

Re: Show HN: I quit coding years ago. AI brought me back

#438

Slightly moving into the other direction, after 17 years of science and tech optimism I see myself turning into a Luddite more and more. First observation was that communication and social aspects of software seems crucial for success and proliferation. And next came: that technology seems inept to solve any socio-econimic problems, but rather aggravates them.

It's not technology that is the problem. It never was. It's Capitalism, always was the problem and always will. It's insane how Capitalism curtails innovation.

The problem is that we are still in the pre-history of civilization. We make some basic mistakes, still. Some of them quite costly, others quite dangerous. As history advances we'll learn to fix it, as long as we don't fixate on just one thing. It's never just one thing.

Re: Show HN: I quit coding years ago. AI brought me back

#439
post #75

Made with care for accuracy. I'm not sure how you can claim this on the footer of every page when you're vibe coding these calculators.

This is more than just a bad side project - it's borderline malicious. How confident is the OP that every single one of these 60 calculators work all the time, with all edge cases? Because if someone is on your website using your calculator, they are putting trust in you. If it's wrong, it could have downstream impacts on them. I hope every single one has a comprehensive set of tests with good edge cases. But realist…

I've been thinking a bit about vibe coding with trust-critical apps. My solution has been hand-code and test the parts where bugs would mislead users, and vibe code the rest. In my case that's been hand-coding backend calculation logic and vibe coding the UI and server (this is also the part I am least expert in). In practice this does wind up including a lot of little judgment calls at the interfaces.

In the end, my feeling is there needs to be transparency in how bulletproof-tested a product is. IMO even a calculator that might be wrong can be useful if it's the most convenient option and the user knows the risks (though to be clear, that is not the philosophy I am employing in my personal project).

Post reply on HN