Live data from Hacker News

OLED, Not for Me

nuxx.net

1–10 of 221 posts

Re: OLED, Not for Me

#2
tl;dr

The display the author doesn't like is a specific model Dell QD-OLED with a sub pixel arrangement that causes a fringe above / below text.

There are macro screenshots that reveal the sub pixel details of a preferred LCD compared the disliked Dell OLED, and it's easy to agree with the author's discontentment.

But the categorical complaint about "OLED" is an over generalization.

Treat the report as a warning to investigate the sub pixel characteristics of any monitor you may be considering.

Re: OLED, Not for Me

#3
post #2

tl;dr The display the author doesn't like is a specific model Dell QD-OLED with a sub pixel arrangement that causes a fringe above / below text. There are macro screenshots that reveal the sub pixel details of a preferred LCD compared the disliked Dell OLED, and it's easy to agree with the author's discontentment. But the categorical complaint about "OLED" is an over generalization. Treat the report as a warning to i…

Agreed. Personally, I find WOLED quite comfortable, especially for text, since I spend 90% of my time looking at terminals: white text on a black background. Having the vast majority of the display off feels wonderful.

Re: OLED, Not for Me

#4
post #2

tl;dr The display the author doesn't like is a specific model Dell QD-OLED with a sub pixel arrangement that causes a fringe above / below text. There are macro screenshots that reveal the sub pixel details of a preferred LCD compared the disliked Dell OLED, and it's easy to agree with the author's discontentment. But the categorical complaint about "OLED" is an over generalization. Treat the report as a warning to i…

Author also thought it might be a backlight failed for his first oled problem....

Re: OLED, Not for Me

#5
It's so hard to find OLEDs with a sensible subpixel layout these days. I wish this stuff were documented and that you could find traditional horizontal subpixel layouts in the OLED mass market.

I have at least one friend who wants individually-addressible bayer layouts, but that likely won't happen.

Re: OLED, Not for Me

#6
I picked up the same monitor as the author. I'm pretty happy with it myself - I have the Pro-Art display that the author has as well, and the volume of color makes a huge difference for me.

But OLED is a remarkably personal technology. Some people also have issues with how the images are "strobed" during upgrades, etc.

Re: OLED, Not for Me

#7
The gaming community has known this forever, it’s a personal preference for how much it bothers someone.

But fret not, they announced at CES there will be OLED with vertical pixel arrangements really soon.

Re: OLED, Not for Me

#8
This was a validating read. I used a Samsung G9 OLED for the better part of a year and eventually had to stop because the eye strain was terrible. I found myself avoiding my desk because it was a chore to look at the display.

I've moved back to using a pair of 4K LCDs that I had, and honestly the resolution and aspect ratio are better for text and programming anyhow.

Re: OLED, Not for Me

#9
I experienced the same issue with the Alienware 27" 360 Hz OLED monitor. While it was great for gaming and I loved the refresh rate, it was terrible for everything else. Text always looked blurry, my eyes would keep trying to focus it and tired themselves out. I started getting headaches and began to doubt my prescription. After months of investigation, visits to the optometrist, I finally narrowed it down to the monitor being the culprit. I gave it away to my son, who on the other hand was thrilled to receive a bonafide gaming monitor. He uses it at 2x scaling and couldn't be happier.

These monitors are great when scaled but have real issues rendering text and other fine details at their native resolution.

Re: OLED, Not for Me

#10
I just recently picked up a 49" Samsung G9 OLED and also had a similar experience. It felt like the picture was moving and I couldn't focus correctly. I first chalked it up to the low PPI, but after some googling, it was text fringing.
Post reply on HN