Live data from Hacker News

Game Over

antirez.com

1–10 of 99 posts

Re: Game Over

#2
While I agree that vitriol isn't the best response to someone displaying a lack of understanding, as you did, I hope you don't get defensive and instead try to learn something from the people who made reasonable critiques of your thoughts. Because they need some adjusting.

Re: Game Over

#3
post #2

While I agree that vitriol isn't the best response to someone displaying a lack of understanding, as you did, I hope you don't get defensive and instead try to learn something from the people who made reasonable critiques of your thoughts. Because they need some adjusting.

Hint: you are saying that my thoughts need to be "adjusted".

Re: Game Over

#4
post #2

While I agree that vitriol isn't the best response to someone displaying a lack of understanding, as you did, I hope you don't get defensive and instead try to learn something from the people who made reasonable critiques of your thoughts. Because they need some adjusting.

[deleted]

Re: Game Over

#5
post #4
post #2

While I agree that vitriol isn't the best response to someone displaying a lack of understanding, as you did, I hope you don't get defensive and instead try to learn something from the people who made reasonable critiques of your thoughts. Because they need some adjusting.

[deleted]

Being critical about yourself is probably not your greatest asset. Just my impression from your two comments here...

Re: Game Over

#6
Is there a link to the thing that happened to set off this post? I read the previous post and its comments and saw nothing out of the ordinary.

Re: Game Over

#7
post #3
post #2

While I agree that vitriol isn't the best response to someone displaying a lack of understanding, as you did, I hope you don't get defensive and instead try to learn something from the people who made reasonable critiques of your thoughts. Because they need some adjusting.

Hint: you are saying that my thoughts need to be "adjusted".

I don't think he stuttered--he laid his point out his succinctly.

What exactly were people taking issue with? I couldn't tell from the post.

Re: Game Over

#8
Some people are going to say that he was in the right, and some will argue this is a consequence of being wrong, but this doesn't matter. What this illustrates is the dangerous precipice that the world of blogging is hanging on to, where the violent hatred that spews forth when anyone writes a remotely controversial opinion threatens to silence any opinion that sways too far from mainstream consciousness.

The fact that the first comment that was posted here was just more critique about the original blog post and how supposedly "wrong" it was illustrates how much of a problem this has become. Whether or not his opinion is wrong doesn't matter. What matters is that he expresses it as an alternative perspective to mainstream conciousness.

Problems are solved and society is moved forward by a multitude of various opinions, all right and wrong in their own ways, interacting with each other. Each perspective provides a unique method of solving a problem which may not yet exist. The more perspectives we have, the more ideas we have to work from when we try to solve a problem.

By violently critiquing such controversial stances, we are indirectly silencing those voices, and ultimately destroying our own ability to find progressively better solutions to problems, because we get stuck inside a single point of view and refuse to move outside of it. It is not simply a matter of ignoring trolls either, because many of the most hurtful comments, at least in my experience, are otherwise highly intelligent people who completely missed the point of what you were trying to say, and have spent 10 minutes writing a scathing critique against a nonexistent problem.

If we continue to censor ourselves, it will destroy us.

"I may not agree with what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it." - Voltaire

Re: Game Over

#9

Is there a link to the thing that happened to set off this post? I read the previous post and its comments and saw nothing out of the ordinary.

long story short, a blog post about sexism I wrote generated a reply that remembered me that I was probably not in a communication environment I was happy to be in... so I'm finding new ways to communicate that don't involve tweets.

Re: Game Over

#10
post #5
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[deleted]

Being critical about yourself is probably not your greatest asset. Just my impression from your two comments here...

Certainly noted
Post reply on HN