Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: idea for the future of document editing

doc-edit.herokuapp.com

41–50 of 54 posts

Re: Show HN: idea for the future of document editing

#43
This is really cool and I can definitely see it being useful once the kinks are worked out.

Without repeating most of the feedback given already, I’ve noticed that it picks up too many pointless words. I’d suggest making it more selective with the words picked out to be relevant. Quality over quantity.

Re: Show HN: idea for the future of document editing

#46
post #39

An interesting idea, but it comes up with really, really useless suggestion -- I don't think anybody needs to be told what don't is, west may be a cardinal direction but 'in the west we enjoy' does not refer to particular side of a compass. Also for some reason it blinks with 1. AD is a year (I did write the word one, but it really shouldn't blink).

I see it as an interface demo, not a search results demo.

obviously you would connect it to the best search results at your disposal. that's a different problem entirely.

Re: Show HN: idea for the future of document editing

#49

Great job! I encourage you to continue improving it. I pasted a Paul Graham essay and the results were telling: https://dl.dropbox.com/u/315/random_pics/nlp1.png https://dl.dropbox.com/u/315/random_pics/nlp2.png https://dl.dropbox.com/u/315/random_pics/nlp3.png https://dl.dropbox.com/u/315/random_pics/nlp4.png In short, the results aren't relevant at all -- either to the author or to his audience. (The third screensh…

Another test case: I pasted a couple paragraphs of John Gruber's Kindle review in there, and it shows me (only) "Fleetwood Mac" (derived from the phrase "my Mac"), and "I Love" (the country music song, from the sentence "I love glowing screens").

It skipped terms that seem to me much more obvious links, like "iPhone", "iPad", "TiVo", "ATM", "Kindle", "credit card", "supermarket", or "e-ink".

Post reply on HN