Live data from Hacker News

Git over FTP

github.com

11–20 of 41 posts

Re: Git over FTP

#11
post #10

Nifty project. But I have hard time believing that there still are web providers that don't support SSH. Are there any? Good ones?

Free hosting sites generally don't provide SSH access. I'm using 000webhost.com currently, which doesn't.

Re: Git over FTP

#13
post #10

Nifty project. But I have hard time believing that there still are web providers that don't support SSH. Are there any? Good ones?

Rackspace cloud sites - though we use SSHFS for git.

Re: Git over FTP

#15
post #5

This is extremely interesting. I think the main people to benefit from this would be self-deployment kind of people or freelance developers. Mostly freelance devs I believe. For my stuff, I'd definitely use this - but my first order of business would be to talk people into getting proper hosting so I wouldn't have to. Obviously that's not possible for freelance gigs. I'll definitely use it when I need to deploy to X…

The only useful infrastructure that my university will give me is a login account on an ancient (locked down) solaris box, and an ftp account. I could make ftp:// links shareable to colleagues and point them to tortoisegit as a useful client for accessing and editing said stuff using their existing login credentials (via judicious use of chmod) and this would solve a significant problem.

Re: Git over FTP

#18
An interesting way of implementing this may be to flip the responsibility of 'translation'.

Here the git client includes logic to speak (translate to) ftp - which is great for this purpose.

What if you could say: `git push fleet master`

where fleet is a remote that translates git-speak into a deployment.

I realize - this is simply an imitation of Heroku. But, it may be interesting to flex git in this way: a code change protocol.

This and the recently discussed codeq could yield some very interesting possibilities.

Re: Git over FTP

#19
With your advanced ftp technology you are blinding me with your retro chic. I need git over smoke signals. Nothing else is 19th century enough.

Seriously, other than it was a fun fidget, what was the point?

Post reply on HN