Live data from Hacker News

Stranger Things creator says turn off “garbage” settings

screenrant.com

21–30 of 834 posts

Re: Stranger Things creator says turn off “garbage” settings

#21

All the settings in the world won't change the story.

Careful what you wish for, or we might get AI-powered "Vibrant Story" filters that reduce 62 minutes of plot-less filler to a 5 minute summary of the only relevant points. Or that try to generate some logic to make the magic in the story make narrative sense.

Re: Stranger Things creator says turn off “garbage” settings

#22
post #3

what about not filming entire show in darkness. or, i don't know, filming it in a way that it will look ok on modern televisions without having to turn off settings.

Or specially.. stopping at season 2 of this show.

This is the way.

Re: Stranger Things creator says turn off “garbage” settings

#24

All the settings in the world won't change the story.

Careful what you wish for, or we might get AI-powered "Vibrant Story" filters that reduce 62 minutes of plot-less filler to a 5 minute summary of the only relevant points. Or that try to generate some logic to make the magic in the story make narrative sense.

as opposite to AI-powered "Hyper Vibrant Story" filters that increase 5 minute of plot to 62 minutes of slop

Re: Stranger Things creator says turn off “garbage” settings

#25

Yeah, televisions come full of truly destructive settings. I think part of the genesis of this virus is the need for TV's to stand out at the store. Brands and models are displayed side-by-side. The only way to stand out is to push the limits of over-enhancement along every possible axis (resolution, color, motion, etc.). Since consumers are not trained to critically discern image and video quality, the "Wow!" often…

[deleted]

Re: Stranger Things creator says turn off “garbage” settings

#26
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Careful what you wish for, or we might get AI-powered "Vibrant Story" filters that reduce 62 minutes of plot-less filler to a 5 minute summary of the only relevant points. Or that try to generate some logic to make the magic in the story make narrative sense.

as opposite to AI-powered "Hyper Vibrant Story" filters that increase 5 minute of plot to 62 minutes of slop

Much like a chain of email AI filters that turn short directions into full-fledged emails, that in turn get summarized into short directions on the receiving end.

Re: Stranger Things creator says turn off “garbage” settings

#28

Yeah, kiss m'ass. I agree that some of those settings do need to be turned off. When I visit someone and see their TV on soap opera mode, I fight the urge to fix it. Not my house, not my TV, not my problem if they like it that way, and yet, wow, is it ever awful. But then getting into recommendations like "turn off vivid mode" is pretty freaking pretentious, in my opinion, like a restaurant where the chef freaks out…

> What if I need higher contrast to make out what's happening on the screen?

The point you make isn't incorrect at all. I would say that TV's should ship without any such enhancements enabled. The user should then be able to configure it as they wish.

Plenty of parallel examples of this: Microsoft should ship a "clean" version of Windows. Users can they opt into whatever they might want to add.

Social media sites should default to the most private non-public sharing settings. Users can open it up to the world if they wish. Their choice.

Going back to TV's: They should not ship with spyware, log-ware, behavioral tracking and advertising crap. Users can opt into that stuff if they value proposition being offered appeals to them.

Etc.

Re: Stranger Things creator says turn off “garbage” settings

#30

Implying that makes a bad season better. When you watch thrash settings doesn't really matter

I don't think it implies that at all.

It is perfectly understandable that the people who really care about how their work was colour-graded, then suggest you turn off all the features that shit all over that work. Similarly for the other settings he mentions.

Don't get me wrong, I haven't seen the first season, so won't watch this, but creators / artists do and should care about this stuff.

Of course, people can watch things in whatever dreaded settings they want, but lots of TVs default to bad settings, so awareness is good.

Post reply on HN