Live data from Hacker News

Do Female Executives Drive Start-up Success?

diegobasch.com

1–10 of 44 posts

Re: Do Female Executives Drive Start-up Success?

#2
I don't know about female executives, but female hackers are a pleasure to work with. I'm lucky to be working with two right now on Nuuton, and its just great. Very smart hackers without the testosterone driven need to prove themselves on every opportunity. They just work independently and give great feedback. They are a key driver of the success of Nuuton.

Re: Do Female Executives Drive Start-up Success?

#3
If I'm reading the study correctly the impact seems to be: 1) There is a correlation between female execs and success, so companies that tend to do better are also companies that tend to have female executives. 2) We can't make any statements about causation, so this means it's not effective for companies to just say let's hire female executives--without fixing any underlying reasons they didn't before. In fact I'd guess it's more likely that both success and having female executives is a result of a better firm culture/outlook rather than one of them being the direct cause of the other.

Re: Do Female Executives Drive Start-up Success?

#4

I don't know about female executives, but female hackers are a pleasure to work with. I'm lucky to be working with two right now on Nuuton, and its just great. Very smart hackers without the testosterone driven need to prove themselves on every opportunity. They just work independently and give great feedback. They are a key driver of the success of Nuuton.

I agree. My team at LinkedIn was awesome in that respect. There were several women on it. They were extremely talented from a technical perspective, and their communication skills were great. I'd echo what you said.

Re: Do Female Executives Drive Start-up Success?

#6
Out of curiosity, I often read gender/green studies mentioned in mainstresm press, published by various NGO. I am constantly horrified how misused statistics is. I believe that most of these studies are written for a specific purpose and math is there just to give it a science-cover. Even worse, I hear them cited by politicians making a real impact to our lives.

Re: Do Female Executives Drive Start-up Success?

#8
It doesn't appear that they controlled for the size of the company. So it could be that larger companies in the survey (but still "startups") have more females, since they hired and few founders are women.

Not that women don't drive startup success! But DJ disappoints on statistical analysis.

Re: Do Female Executives Drive Start-up Success?

#9
One other factor that's missing from the study is the level of success achieved by the companies. Instead of just grouping companies into "Generating Revenue"/"Profitable" or "IPO'd", they should have done a breakdown by how successful the company is. If the stereotype that bell curves for men and women have the different stdevs is true, then the data would show that companies founded by men have both a higher chance of failure (higher risk) but also a larger return on investment. Unfortunately, most gender based studies tend to only care about the means of the samples and ignore the stdevs. For something like the founding of a successful company, the black swans at the tail of the bell curves matter more than the rest of the bell curve which consists of failures or mediocre successes.

Re: Do Female Executives Drive Start-up Success?

#10
Personally, I don't really give a hoot about the gender of who I work with - pleasing aesthetics are nice, but I'd work with Swamp Thing if he'd get the job done.

I'm sure there's just as many well spoken, even-keeled men as there are women, and perhaps women do come out of this test better than men. Maybe because they have to work harder to overcome discrimination, maybe because they charm their way into the mainly male start-up work-force.

Again, it doesn't matter. Don't go out looking for particular genders, because all you're doing is limiting yourself.

tldr: tldr.

Post reply on HN