Live data from Hacker News

Snitch – A friendlier ss/netstat

github.com

11–20 of 109 posts

Re: Snitch – A friendlier ss/netstat

#14
I just want a single tool that has a known, generalized set of capabilities on just about every distribution.

Systemd's obsession with remaking every single wheel in Linux has been aggravating enough. Please don't do it again.

Re: Snitch – A friendlier ss/netstat

#15

I always wondered how useful such tools are against a competent adversary. If you are a competent engineer designing malware, wouldn't you introduce a dormancy period into your malware executable and if possible only talk to C&C while the user is doing something that talks to other endpoints? Maybe even choose the communication protocol based on what the user is doing to blend in even better.

agreed on the limits. snitch isnt aimed at adversarial detection; its a local debugging/inspection tool. a competent attacker can blend in by design, so this isnt meant to be a standalone security control

With a name like Snitch, it should be aimed at adversarial detection.

Just my two snitches.

Re: Snitch – A friendlier ss/netstat

#16
post #9
post #8

When I saw this headline I assumed it was Little Snitch an existing network monitor and firewall for Macs. Might need a different name. https://www.obdev.at/products/littlesnitch/index.html

There's also a Linux clone of little snitch, OpenSnitch.

There's also https://github.com/snitch-org/snitch with the AUR package name 'snitch'.

Re: Snitch – A friendlier ss/netstat

#17
post #5

I always wondered how useful such tools are against a competent adversary. If you are a competent engineer designing malware, wouldn't you introduce a dormancy period into your malware executable and if possible only talk to C&C while the user is doing something that talks to other endpoints? Maybe even choose the communication protocol based on what the user is doing to blend in even better.

Tools like these aren't really intended for adversarial environments, and pure network tools that are designed for real adversaries have a really spotty track record (good search: [bro vantage point problem]).

That search did not come up with much. Can you elaborate?

Re: Snitch – A friendlier ss/netstat

#18
post #8

When I saw this headline I assumed it was Little Snitch an existing network monitor and firewall for Macs. Might need a different name. https://www.obdev.at/products/littlesnitch/index.html

Seems like a fine name. Why would little snitch existing necessitate a name change?

Re: Snitch – A friendlier ss/netstat

#19

I just want a single tool that has a known, generalized set of capabilities on just about every distribution. Systemd's obsession with remaking every single wheel in Linux has been aggravating enough. Please don't do it again.

No-one is stopping you from using netstat.
Post reply on HN