Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Claude Code gets native LSP support

github.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

61–70 of 352 posts

Re: Claude Code gets native LSP support

#61

Post by shermantanktop »

anthonypasq wrote: post #42
spullara wrote: post #31

I really can't understand why JetBrains hasn't integrated its refactoring tools into the AI system. Really missed the boat on making their platform transformational for AI coding. Imagine how much smaller the context would be for a tool that renames a function than editing hundreds of files. This LSP support is a good start but without the mutation functions it is still pretty lackluster. Plus LSPs aren't as good as…

there is a jetbrains MCP server that gives Claude Code access to this sort of thing, but I think its still fairly jank and bloats context.

I never got it to work, but in the process of trying it became obvious that it’s an under-resourced feature.

Re: Claude Code gets native LSP support

#62

Post by Aiisnotabubble »

frays wrote: post #54
brianyu8 wrote: post #11

I am super bullish on claude code / codex cli + LSP and other deterministic codemod and code intelligence tools. I was playing around with codex this weekend and honestly having a great time (my opinion of it has 180'd since gpt-5.2(-codex) came out) but I was getting annoyed at it because it kept missing references when I asked it to rename or move symbols. So I built a skill that teaches it to use rope for mechanic…

Interesting to see that you work at OpenAI but had to build a skill like this yourself. Surprised that you don't have internal tools or skills that could do this already! Shows how much more work there is still to be done in this space.

[dead]

Re: Claude Code gets native LSP support

#63

Post by shermantanktop »

frays wrote: post #54
brianyu8 wrote: post #11

I am super bullish on claude code / codex cli + LSP and other deterministic codemod and code intelligence tools. I was playing around with codex this weekend and honestly having a great time (my opinion of it has 180'd since gpt-5.2(-codex) came out) but I was getting annoyed at it because it kept missing references when I asked it to rename or move symbols. So I built a skill that teaches it to use rope for mechanic…

Interesting to see that you work at OpenAI but had to build a skill like this yourself. Surprised that you don't have internal tools or skills that could do this already! Shows how much more work there is still to be done in this space.

Cobbler’s children…

Re: Claude Code gets native LSP support

#64

Post by dvtkrlbs »

What boggles my mind is. I've been using OpenCode [1] which had this future for at least 6 months. I sometimes baffled by the slow progress of closed source software. Also highly recommend OpenCode you can also use it with your Claude subscription or Copilot one.

[1]: https://opencode.ai/

Re: Claude Code gets native LSP support

#65

Post by dvtkrlbs »

parpfish wrote: post #41
spullara wrote: post #31

I really can't understand why JetBrains hasn't integrated its refactoring tools into the AI system. Really missed the boat on making their platform transformational for AI coding. Imagine how much smaller the context would be for a tool that renames a function than editing hundreds of files. This LSP support is a good start but without the mutation functions it is still pretty lackluster. Plus LSPs aren't as good as…

Jetbrainz needs to give up on Junie and their in house ai and focus on integrating with the established tools. If they don’t, VS code will consume them.

They already kinda did. They brough ACP support which allows you to somewhat integrate Claude Code, Gemini CLI or OpenCode they also recently brought BYOK support so you can use an existing provider and don't pay extra subscription for it.

Re: Claude Code gets native LSP support

#66

Post by voiper1 »

frays wrote: post #54
brianyu8 wrote: post #11

I am super bullish on claude code / codex cli + LSP and other deterministic codemod and code intelligence tools. I was playing around with codex this weekend and honestly having a great time (my opinion of it has 180'd since gpt-5.2(-codex) came out) but I was getting annoyed at it because it kept missing references when I asked it to rename or move symbols. So I built a skill that teaches it to use rope for mechanic…

Interesting to see that you work at OpenAI but had to build a skill like this yourself. Surprised that you don't have internal tools or skills that could do this already! Shows how much more work there is still to be done in this space.

My theory is that even if the models are frozen here, we'll still spend a decade building out all the tooling, connections, skills, etc and getting it into each industry. There's so much _around_ the models that we're still working on too.

Re: Claude Code gets native LSP support

#67

Post by NitpickLawyer »

frays wrote: post #54
brianyu8 wrote: post #11

I am super bullish on claude code / codex cli + LSP and other deterministic codemod and code intelligence tools. I was playing around with codex this weekend and honestly having a great time (my opinion of it has 180'd since gpt-5.2(-codex) came out) but I was getting annoyed at it because it kept missing references when I asked it to rename or move symbols. So I built a skill that teaches it to use rope for mechanic…

Interesting to see that you work at OpenAI but had to build a skill like this yourself. Surprised that you don't have internal tools or skills that could do this already! Shows how much more work there is still to be done in this space.

> Shows how much more work there is still to be done in this space.

This is why I roll my eyes every time I read doomer content that mentions an AI bubble followed by an AI winter. Even if (and objectively there's 0 chance of this happening anytime soon) everyone stops developing models tomorrow, we'll still have 5+ years of finding out how to extract every bit of value from the current models.

Re: Claude Code gets native LSP support

#68

Post by kbar13 »

dvtkrlbs wrote: post #64

What boggles my mind is. I've been using OpenCode [1] which had this future for at least 6 months. I sometimes baffled by the slow progress of closed source software. Also highly recommend OpenCode you can also use it with your Claude subscription or Copilot one. [1]: https://opencode.ai/

i'm not sure i agree with the assessment that claude code has been moving slowly... but it is cool that opencode has had this for a while. will def check it out

Re: Claude Code gets native LSP support

#70

Post by CuriouslyC »

dvtkrlbs wrote: post #65
parpfish wrote: post #41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Jetbrainz needs to give up on Junie and their in house ai and focus on integrating with the established tools. If they don’t, VS code will consume them.

They already kinda did. They brough ACP support which allows you to somewhat integrate Claude Code, Gemini CLI or OpenCode they also recently brought BYOK support so you can use an existing provider and don't pay extra subscription for it.

ACP seems super under the radar. It has some support, but it got merged into A2A, which I don't hear anyone talking about, so it seems like it's going to die on the vine.
Post reply on HN