Live data from Hacker News

AMD Ryzen 7 5800X3D sells for more than 9800X3D, enthusiasts flock to AM4 DDR4

tomshardware.com

31–40 of 75 posts

Re: AMD Ryzen 7 5800X3D sells for more than 9800X3D, enthusiasts flock to AM4 DDR4

#31
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

5800x3d / 5700x3d are MUCH MUCH MUCH faster than non-x3d in some games that are CPU bound (for some even 2x / 3x faster than non-x3d) so even with a "slower" GPU it can still be a large upgrade

when you game in 4K thats only relevant for games like factorio or city skylines.

world of warcraft has a huge speedup on x3d

Re: AMD Ryzen 7 5800X3D sells for more than 9800X3D, enthusiasts flock to AM4 DDR4

#32
post #3

Based on the benchmarks that I've seen, 5800X3D is still a good CPU for games, when paired with a very expensive GPU, otherwise a 5600X is cheaper and acts less than a heater over the winter. Someone with the money for a nVidia 5800 GPU will pair it with a 9800X3D, for most games even 16 GB of RAM will work and would be cheap enough, while for applications one does not need X3D, so what exactly is the point of 5800X3…

> so what exactly is the point of 5800X3D scalping in the past, growth in PC gaming came naturally with the growth in the adoption of computers around the world. at saturation of "new to computers" audiences, growth in PC gaming comes from convincing the core gaming demographic, newly-turned 13 year old boys, to agitate for PCs instead of XYZ. so a big part of it is the retail-marketing experience - the aesthetics of…

Pc gaming is also massively cheaper than consoles these days so the lifetime cost is lower

Re: AMD Ryzen 7 5800X3D sells for more than 9800X3D, enthusiasts flock to AM4 DDR4

#34

Rocking my 5800x from 2022, 32gb ram.

Hell yeah, buddy.

    $ cat /proc/cpuinfo
    ...
    model name      : AMD Ryzen 7 5800X 8-Core Processor

    $ free -m
    ...
                   total        used        free      shared  buff/cache   available
    Mem:           32006        6878        1088         363       24856       25127

Re: AMD Ryzen 7 5800X3D sells for more than 9800X3D, enthusiasts flock to AM4 DDR4

#35
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

when you game in 4K thats only relevant for games like factorio or city skylines.

world of warcraft has a huge speedup on x3d

in the main capital, yes. but even in raids i hit 120 fps in 4k with my 5800x.

Re: AMD Ryzen 7 5800X3D sells for more than 9800X3D, enthusiasts flock to AM4 DDR4

#36
post #3

Based on the benchmarks that I've seen, 5800X3D is still a good CPU for games, when paired with a very expensive GPU, otherwise a 5600X is cheaper and acts less than a heater over the winter. Someone with the money for a nVidia 5800 GPU will pair it with a 9800X3D, for most games even 16 GB of RAM will work and would be cheap enough, while for applications one does not need X3D, so what exactly is the point of 5800X3…

> 5600X is cheaper and acts less than a heater over the winter It’s impossible to keep my 5800x below 90C under full load.

Then you need better cooling. The stock coolers are pretty mediocre.

Re: AMD Ryzen 7 5800X3D sells for more than 9800X3D, enthusiasts flock to AM4 DDR4

#37
post #3

Based on the benchmarks that I've seen, 5800X3D is still a good CPU for games, when paired with a very expensive GPU, otherwise a 5600X is cheaper and acts less than a heater over the winter. Someone with the money for a nVidia 5800 GPU will pair it with a 9800X3D, for most games even 16 GB of RAM will work and would be cheap enough, while for applications one does not need X3D, so what exactly is the point of 5800X3…

You are simply not making any meaningful amount of heat with a 5800X3D. You're talking about a TDP of 105W and a PPT of 142W.

Re: AMD Ryzen 7 5800X3D sells for more than 9800X3D, enthusiasts flock to AM4 DDR4

#39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> so what exactly is the point of 5800X3D scalping in the past, growth in PC gaming came naturally with the growth in the adoption of computers around the world. at saturation of "new to computers" audiences, growth in PC gaming comes from convincing the core gaming demographic, newly-turned 13 year old boys, to agitate for PCs instead of XYZ. so a big part of it is the retail-marketing experience - the aesthetics of…

Pc gaming is also massively cheaper than consoles these days so the lifetime cost is lower

How?

Consoles don’t pay for online subscriptions with f2p games anymore, which is the overwhelming lions share of online play today.

Consoles also get to flip games you’re done with. I’m positive about 3 of my friends spend much less than I do on gaming these days because of all the games they buy, play once, then flip again on FB market place

And then you get to the rising entry level cost of PC gaming. If you want something better than a Steam deck you’re looking at 1K USD to start with an Intel dGPU

But I guess if you’re fine with a Steam deck it’s a bit cheaper than consoles to start

The best claim that PC gaming has today is that it has a much larger library with indies that don’t release on console

Re: AMD Ryzen 7 5800X3D sells for more than 9800X3D, enthusiasts flock to AM4 DDR4

#40
post #10
post #8

Be careful with these older boards. Some might be PCIe 3.0 making your GPU and NVMe dog slow.

Even like 2016 vintage boards were PCIe 4.0 so I don’t think this is a huge issue?

Considering the final PCIe 4.0 spec was released in June 2017 that seems improbable.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PCI_Express

AMD didn't even support PCIe 4.0 until 2019 with Zen 2, Intel in 2020 with tiger lake.

Post reply on HN