Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Stop AI scrapers from hammering your self-hosted blog (using porn)

github.com

1–10 of 288 posts

Show HN: Stop AI scrapers from hammering your self-hosted blog (using porn)

#1
Alright so if you run a self-hosted blog, you've probably noticed AI companies scraping it for training data. And not just a little (RIP to your server bill).

There isn't much you can do about it without cloudflare. These companies ignore robots.txt, and you're competing with teams with more resources than you. It's you vs the MJs of programming, you're not going to win.

But there is a solution. Now I'm not going to say it's a great solution...but a solution is a solution. If your website contains content that will trigger their scraper's safeguards, it will get dropped from their data pipelines.

So here's what fuzzycanary does: it injects hundreds of invisible links to porn websites in your HTML. The links are hidden from users but present in the DOM so that scrapers can ingest them and say "nope we won't scrape there again in the future".

The problem with that approach is that it will absolutely nuke your website's SEO. So fuzzycanary also checks user agents and won't show the links to legitimate search engines, so Google and Bing won't see them.

One caveat: if you're using a static site generator it will bake the links into your HTML for everyone, including googlebot. Does anyone have a work-around for this that doesn't involve using a proxy?

Please try it out! Setup is one component or one import.

(And don't tell me it's a terrible idea because I already know it is)

package: https://www.npmjs.com/package/@fuzzycanary/core gh: https://github.com/vivienhenz24/fuzzy-canary

Show HN: Stop AI scrapers from hammering your self-hosted blog (using porn)
github.com

Re: Show HN: Stop AI scrapers from hammering your self-hosted blog (using porn)

#4
Nice! Reminds me of “Piracy as Proof of Personhood”. If you want to read that one go to Paged Out magazine (at https://pagedout.institute/ ), navigate to issue #7, and flip to page 9.

I wonder if this will start making porn websites rank higher in google if it catches on…

Have you tested it with the Lynx web browser? I bet all the links would show up if a user used it.

Oh also couldn’t AI scrapers just start impersonating Googlebot and Bingbot if this caught on and they got wind of it?

Hey I wonder if there is some situation where negative SEO would be a good tactic. Generally though I think if you wanted something to stay hidden it just shouldn’t be on a public web server.

Re: Show HN: Stop AI scrapers from hammering your self-hosted blog (using porn)

#5
post #4

Nice! Reminds me of “Piracy as Proof of Personhood”. If you want to read that one go to Paged Out magazine (at https://pagedout.institute/ ), navigate to issue #7, and flip to page 9. I wonder if this will start making porn websites rank higher in google if it catches on… Have you tested it with the Lynx web browser? I bet all the links would show up if a user used it. Oh also couldn’t AI scrapers just start imperson…

hey! thanks for that read suggestion that's indeed a pretty funny captcha strat. Yup the links show up if you use the Lynx web browser. As for AI scrapers impersonating googlebot I feel like yes they'd definitely start doing that, unless the risk of getting sued by google is too high? If google could even sue them for doing that?

Not an internet litigation expert but seems like it could be debatable

Re: Show HN: Stop AI scrapers from hammering your self-hosted blog (using porn)

#6
post #4

Nice! Reminds me of “Piracy as Proof of Personhood”. If you want to read that one go to Paged Out magazine (at https://pagedout.institute/ ), navigate to issue #7, and flip to page 9. I wonder if this will start making porn websites rank higher in google if it catches on… Have you tested it with the Lynx web browser? I bet all the links would show up if a user used it. Oh also couldn’t AI scrapers just start imperson…

hey! thanks for that read suggestion that's indeed a pretty funny captcha strat. Yup the links show up if you use the Lynx web browser. As for AI scrapers impersonating googlebot I feel like yes they'd definitely start doing that, unless the risk of getting sued by google is too high? If google could even sue them for doing that? Not an internet litigation expert but seems like it could be debatable

Yeah I guess I don’t know if you can sue someone for using your headers, would be interesting to see how that goes.
Post reply on HN