Live data from Hacker News

Map of all the buildings in the world

gizmodo.com

51–60 of 67 posts

Re: Map of all the buildings in the world

#51
post #27

They've used a vision transformer to estimate building heights from monocular aerial photographs, so they're guesses at best. Calling this a map is a stretch.

I checked the building heights where I live vs the actual heights, sometimes they display the height as half of what the actual height is.

I found a few that are off by a factor of about 4. Always lower than in reality, never taller.

Re: Map of all the buildings in the world

#52

What is the crowd process to upgrade/correct this? I notice massive errors in small Midwest US towns (multiple buildings being combined/ommitted, etc)?

It's machine-learning generated "slop" honestly. Looking at where I live and where I grew up the building heights are quite badly estimated. - Some groups of houses around here that are more or less identically built but on sloped terrain are reported to have widly differing heights - My neighbour building is reported to be half the height of this building (they're more or less equally high at 5 stories) - A small of…

Or, they subtracted a digital elevation model from a digital surface model, ran a point-in-polygon match against an existing building dataset, and labelled the difference as the height of the building. No ML needed.

Re: Map of all the buildings in the world

#53
I've had a project idea in the back of my mind for a long time: take all of my locations that I've saved in Swarm (https://swarmapp.com) and 3D render all of the buildings that I've been to. The issue was a lack of models of the actual buildings - which is here! Maybe it is possible...

Re: Map of all the buildings in the world

#54
post #45

The height measure when you click on a building is not very accurate. Clicked on two next to each other (one single floor and one with two floors) and the single story house was marked taller by the site.

Can confirm. My garage is marked double the height of my actual house. Both are incorrect. My shop building on my property, next to the garage is actually missing.

The positioning of the shapes in relation to each other are also wrong. And not in a subtle way.

Looked at the house my father built in 1985. A few hundred kilometers from my current location. The shape is wrong (as are the shapes of all neighboring buildings. As are the positions toward each other (distance between houses, rotation of shapes). The heights are also significantly wrong. The two story houses on the opposite side of the road are said to be slightly above 2 meters in height.

Re: Map of all the buildings in the world

#55
post #45

The height measure when you click on a building is not very accurate. Clicked on two next to each other (one single floor and one with two floors) and the single story house was marked taller by the site.

quite a lot of height errors, checked my neighborhood as well, often by orders of magnitude off.

Re: Map of all the buildings in the world

#56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's machine-learning generated "slop" honestly. Looking at where I live and where I grew up the building heights are quite badly estimated. - Some groups of houses around here that are more or less identically built but on sloped terrain are reported to have widly differing heights - My neighbour building is reported to be half the height of this building (they're more or less equally high at 5 stories) - A small of…

Or, they subtracted a digital elevation model from a digital surface model, ran a point-in-polygon match against an existing building dataset, and labelled the difference as the height of the building. No ML needed.

There's a notice in the bottom-left corner on desktop that says: "This is a machine-learning-derived product. Errors may occur"

Re: Map of all the buildings in the world

#58

What is the crowd process to upgrade/correct this? I notice massive errors in small Midwest US towns (multiple buildings being combined/ommitted, etc)?

It's machine-learning generated "slop" honestly. Looking at where I live and where I grew up the building heights are quite badly estimated. - Some groups of houses around here that are more or less identically built but on sloped terrain are reported to have widly differing heights - My neighbour building is reported to be half the height of this building (they're more or less equally high at 5 stories) - A small of…

Still useful for a sense of building density. If almost everything called out is some sort of construction, then the density map of the world is a realistic estimate of human occupation.

Re: Map of all the buildings in the world

#59
post #27

They've used a vision transformer to estimate building heights from monocular aerial photographs, so they're guesses at best. Calling this a map is a stretch.

Hey maps used to have sea serpents and winged griffins. It's a map. Maybe not the best map.

Re: Map of all the buildings in the world

#60
post #10

So here is finally the data that I needed for my idea: walk directions from A to B while never leaving the shadows, suggesting bars and pubs where to wait while the shadows catch up and let you cross “safely” where before was sunny. Useful for scorching weather places like south of Spain.

Currently building something like this for my city. One major challenge I've come across so far is that most APIs will give you coordinates for an address of a place within a building but none of the free, paid or crowdsourced options have reliable information on outside seating polygons. Of course, you could always display the places around you with live shadow data on a map, leaving it up to the user to zoom in and decide based on the satellite image whether the restaurant or café offers outside seating. But to plot the route and then suggest nearby sun/shadow seating options to the user, you would need this information.
Post reply on HN