Live data from Hacker News

Will Rails be the new PHP

roytomeij.com

1–10 of 32 posts

Re: Will Rails be the new PHP

#3
Everybody knows that PHP is infected with bad programmers 'cause is an easy to run language. You have a mac? Just make a .php and you can kill some baby seals with you lame code.

Re: Will Rails be the new PHP

#4
As someone who started life a PHP dev and is now a Rails dev I'm gonna go ahead and say no.

Rails pretty much forces you into using good practices, where as PHP (without a framework) allows you to do all kinds of stupid shit.

If anything, new devs going straight to Ruby on Rails will actually give us less shitty developers.

Re: Will Rails be the new PHP

#8
I dont think so. Having migrated to Ruby and Rails from PHP there are a number of compelling differences that will avert the gloom and doom the author seems to mention:

* Rails is driven/maintained by really high quality developers who adhere to best practices

* The project is well-organized, opinionated and focused, developers tend to follow the one right way of doing things.

* The Rails Ecosystem of gems and plugins has whole gamut of solutions to various engineering problems. These gems vary from excellent to horrible, with the excellent ones floating to the top and become standard for use.

* Rails encompasses best practices that were learned from years of making mistakes with PHP and Java development. It is that much more evolved as a result.

In general, I would say the main difference is Rails seems more top down in the direction of ideas and best practices. People tend to mold themselves and their code to fit with the best practices displayed by core or by seasoned Ruby developers.

PHP on the other hand seems more like a free for all, with little top down influence at all.

Post reply on HN