Live data from Hacker News

Untitled topic

news.ycombinator.com

101–110 of 149 posts

Re: undefined

#101

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Right, but any identification of the Ultimate Purpose is going to be a very vague bad guess. I kind of like "to learn", but besides that I tend to keep returning to a string bag of mixed values that won't boil down to anything neat.

The reason I don't think Destiny can amount to more than a "very vague bad guess" as an intellectual matter is that such a solution would tamper with Free Will.

So, how does this outlook work? What's free will (or Free Will)?

Re: undefined

#102
post #56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Imho that cancelling part was about “I still think about it, I don’t have it closed in my mind”. It was not about cancelling a specific person therefore he didn’t mention the name.

[dead]

I understand. I think many people do. It sounds like this individual was proven right in the retaliation.

Re: undefined

#103

[flagged]

I mean if someone says “be kind to animals get a dog” you already know they don’t quite know what “being kind to animals” is. If they say “all humans end up where I am” (even just in terms of age) you already know they don’t quite know what “all humans” is. At the end of the day though, it’s just an out of touch person trying to pass on something in good faith. Their whistleblowing is an incidental side channel they…

> I mean if someone says “be kind to animals get a dog” you already know they don’t quite know what “being kind to animals” is. If they say “all humans end up where I am” (even just in terms of age) you already know they don’t quite know what “all humans” is.

Oh come on. We can quibble about the quality of the post and OP's character, but you're just blatantly misrepresenting their words. They did not say "get a dog," they said there are "few joys like having a dog." More importantly, it is incredibly obvious that when they say "all humans end up where I am," they're referring to facing death, not the specifics of their age, background, or present circumstances.

Re: undefined

#104

[flagged]

I mean if someone says “be kind to animals get a dog” you already know they don’t quite know what “being kind to animals” is. If they say “all humans end up where I am” (even just in terms of age) you already know they don’t quite know what “all humans” is. At the end of the day though, it’s just an out of touch person trying to pass on something in good faith. Their whistleblowing is an incidental side channel they…

Didn’t mean to get into? The list seems like this was its main purpose, the rest only there to help in that effort. It can all have still been authentic but this isnt exactly a brief parenthetical tangent, and the author has demonstrated its importance by returning to comment further on it in much more detail.

Yours is an ironically awkward comment itself in how it takes on the author’s words given their statement about sock puppets being used to discredit…

Re: undefined

#105
The title alone made me think this should be more of a thing: People writing "life reviews" of the time they've spent so far.

Re: undefined

#106

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The reason I don't think Destiny can amount to more than a "very vague bad guess" as an intellectual matter is that such a solution would tamper with Free Will.

So, how does this outlook work? What's free will (or Free Will)?

What I will argue is something like Plato's Tripartite Soul[1] with the proviso that these are orthogonal dimensions.

Free Will, in this telling, exists on the logos/eros plane of the individual.

Destiny is some target on the plane out there at infinity toward which one navigates over time.

The origin of this coordinate system is the heart, and one may or may not hold a connection to the Creator via the thymos.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plato%27s_theory_of_soul

Re: undefined

#107
What is exactly the point of this post? How is related to HN? Wish you best of luck in your surgery but this post if off topic.

Re: undefined

#108

What is exactly the point of this post? How is related to HN? Wish you best of luck in your surgery but this post if off topic.

Seems the author meant the relationship with HN is supposed to be self evident, but in another reply they also stated clearly the ban was in relation to HN, PG was aware and didn’t make the call but didn’t go against it— just paraphrasing from their reply though.

Re: undefined

#109

What is exactly the point of this post? How is related to HN? Wish you best of luck in your surgery but this post if off topic.

Seems the author meant the relationship with HN is supposed to be self evident, but in another reply they also stated clearly the ban was in relation to HN, PG was aware and didn’t make the call but didn’t go against it— just paraphrasing from their reply though.

[deleted]

Re: undefined

#110

>In 2015, I had a lot of interaction with a startup incubator you know well, and ended up sitting in the discussions and planning around banning and erasing a young programmer we considered a threat to our financial interests, due to his concerns about authoritarianism in technology. In retrospect, he was harmless, but an example had to be made. The decision was made to ban him here, try to get him fired though I don…

Sociopaths also get sick. Just because someone might be dying, it doesn't make them nice people.

There's a reason 'come to Jesus moment' is an expression.

Aka the uncertainty collapse of effective altruism -- in which someone realizes they might die before getting to the altruism part, and have to confront the "effective" things they did without any moral counterbalance.

If someone feels guilty about the things they've done when facing death, then they should immediately take actions that try and redress them.

Otherwise, there's an almost certainty they'll revert to being the same asshole they were so uncomfortable facing in the mirror, after mortal peril has passed.

Being someone different requires action, not just thoughts.

Post reply on HN