Live data from Hacker News

How Charles M Schulz created Charlie Brown and Snoopy (2024)

bbc.com

61–70 of 96 posts

Re: How Charles M Schulz created Charlie Brown and Snoopy (2024)

#61

I think many people have seen only the commercially exploited peanuts imagery. In fact the comics - especially the older ones are incredibly clever and funny and insightful and there’s long running threads and connections and strong characters. Peanuts the tshirt/hat/poster/cup is crass. Peanuts the comic is genius. It exactly the same with Donald Duck and Uncle Scrooge. The commercially exploited imagery is crass an…

See also: The Moomins.

Re: How Charles M Schulz created Charlie Brown and Snoopy (2024)

#62

In France we recognize Snoopy and people would call the whole "world" of the comics "Snoopy". "Peanuts" is unknown. I am 55 for the context. We would somehow recognize Charlie Brown, but not by name. The other characters are basically unknown. The reason is that Peanuts was not part of the mainstream comics books we were reading as children. Threre were two kind of them: proper books such as Astérix, and thick "antho…

This goes for much of Europe. 'Peanuts' is hardly known. Everybody over the age of 40 knows Snoopy, mostly by virtue of it being a strong brand with lots of merchandise in the eighties/nineties.

Time for Peanuts comeback!!

Re: How Charles M Schulz created Charlie Brown and Snoopy (2024)

#63
post #48

Does anyone simply not get how this comic got so popular? I've never read a strip from this comic and once felt anything interesting. It's not a Calvin and Hobbes, it's not a Howard the Duck, it's just... I dunno, cute? I guess people like it because it's kinda cute? I know, I'm being something of a Bah Humbug, but I legitimately cannot see the draw of this comic. It reminds me of Family Circus - no story, just vague…

It might have been more like C&H or Far Side at one time, but by the time of the 80s when I first started reading the funny pages, Peanuts was just another mundane strip.

Re: How Charles M Schulz created Charlie Brown and Snoopy (2024)

#64

I'm a musician, and something I've noticed is that children no longer recognize the "peanuts" theme song.

I quite fond of Winton and Ellis Marsalis album Joe Cool's Blues https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m0_gYNtTTgA&list=PL9KZ1X7EqS... which of course also includes the classic Peanuts theme song.

Re: How Charles M Schulz created Charlie Brown and Snoopy (2024)

#65
post #48

Does anyone simply not get how this comic got so popular? I've never read a strip from this comic and once felt anything interesting. It's not a Calvin and Hobbes, it's not a Howard the Duck, it's just... I dunno, cute? I guess people like it because it's kinda cute? I know, I'm being something of a Bah Humbug, but I legitimately cannot see the draw of this comic. It reminds me of Family Circus - no story, just vague…

The only comic worse is Garfield. I have no idea how anyone enjoys either of them.

Re: How Charles M Schulz created Charlie Brown and Snoopy (2024)

#66
post #48

Does anyone simply not get how this comic got so popular? I've never read a strip from this comic and once felt anything interesting. It's not a Calvin and Hobbes, it's not a Howard the Duck, it's just... I dunno, cute? I guess people like it because it's kinda cute? I know, I'm being something of a Bah Humbug, but I legitimately cannot see the draw of this comic. It reminds me of Family Circus - no story, just vague…

I never enjoyed peanuts but I know Bill watterson the creator of Calvin and Hobbes was a big fan, so there must be something there

Re: How Charles M Schulz created Charlie Brown and Snoopy (2024)

#67
post #48

Does anyone simply not get how this comic got so popular? I've never read a strip from this comic and once felt anything interesting. It's not a Calvin and Hobbes, it's not a Howard the Duck, it's just... I dunno, cute? I guess people like it because it's kinda cute? I know, I'm being something of a Bah Humbug, but I legitimately cannot see the draw of this comic. It reminds me of Family Circus - no story, just vague…

You have forgotten your child mind, Peanuts speaks fluently in the mentality of 7 year olds. It resonates childhood logic and contradiction. It's a masterwork of literature, as that child mindframe would not survive written as traditional prose, but is perfectly suited to a 4 panel comic strip.

Re: How Charles M Schulz created Charlie Brown and Snoopy (2024)

#68
post #48

Does anyone simply not get how this comic got so popular? I've never read a strip from this comic and once felt anything interesting. It's not a Calvin and Hobbes, it's not a Howard the Duck, it's just... I dunno, cute? I guess people like it because it's kinda cute? I know, I'm being something of a Bah Humbug, but I legitimately cannot see the draw of this comic. It reminds me of Family Circus - no story, just vague…

In the 80s I read all the comics compilations from the late 50s -> 70s, that was the golden age of the strip. It was an amazing comic and you'll see why all the strips creators since then were inspired by it.

Re: How Charles M Schulz created Charlie Brown and Snoopy (2024)

#69
As a child of the 70s and 80s, Snoopy was a very big deal, but Peanuts was kind of secondary.

I remember around 2nd grade or so Snoopy Joe Cool was a big deal and I had the t shirts and thermos and lunchbox.

There are of course the Peanuts TV specials, they didn’t have much impact on me personally other than to solidify a like of both Snoopy and his side kick, Woodstock.

For me as a kid, Snoopy and Stocky were the only interesting ones.

Re: How Charles M Schulz created Charlie Brown and Snoopy (2024)

#70

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The Thanksgiving and Christmas specials aired every year, and might still. But who has an antenna any more? I do.

Apple bought the rights years ago, PBS cannot show them anymore, they are now behind a paywall.

They used to (a year or two ago?) host them for free so you didn’t need a sub, is that no longer true?

(Sucks about the pbs part though, didn’t realize they’d stopped that.)

Post reply on HN